Other Issues
Issues with Jude: Dispensing with Jude
Among the twenty-seven books of the traditional New Testament, the Epistle of Jude occupies an anomalous position. Comprising just twenty-five verses (roughly 460 words in Greek), it contains no narrative of Jesus’ ministry, no independent dominical sayings, no exposition of the apostolic kerygma, and no identifiable historical or geographical destination. Instead, it is a brief, fierce polemical tract directed against unnamed antinomian teachers, constructed largely by weaving together warnings from the Hebrew Scriptures with explicit citations and midrashic traditions drawn from Second Temple Jewish pseudepigrapha.
Within the framework of the Apostolic Proximity Principle set forth in The Case for the Core New Testament, New Testament writings are evaluated along a spectrum of historical and canonical authority based on their demonstrable connection to the original apostolic witnesses, their earliest reception across the church, their literary independence, and their fidelity to foundational apostolic teaching.1 Even when the seven Catholic Epistles are grouped broadly as secondary authorities alongside the core foundation of Luke-Acts and the Pauline corpus, closer inspection reveals that the seven do not stand on equal footing. Whereas 1 Peter and 1 John enjoyed early, widespread, and uncontested recognition across the second-century church, Jude, together with 2 Peter (which borrows nearly its entire second chapter from Jude), remained on the fringes of Christian consciousness for centuries.
Three converging lines of historical and philological evidence call into question whether Jude belongs in a critically vetted New Testament canon at all:
- Internal non-apostolic posture and certification of pseudepigrapha: The author explicitly distinguishes himself from the apostles, looks back on the apostolic era in the past tense, and treats two non-canonical pseudepigraphical works, 1 Enoch and the Assumption of Moses, as authentic historical narrative and genuine antediluvian prophecy.
- A centuries-long contested reception (Antilegomena) and a canonical double standard: Jude lacks any verifiable quotation in the entire second century, was classified among the disputed writings (antilegomena) by Eusebius, was excluded from the Syriac Peshitta and the Antiochene school, and was explicitly rejected by many early Christians, as Jerome, Didymus the Blind, and later Martin Luther documented, precisely because of its reliance on apocryphal literature. Moreover, the church’s exclusion of First Clement for certifying the Greco-Roman myth of the Phoenix exposes a striking canonical inconsistency when compared with the retention of Jude despite its certification of First Enoch.
- A uniquely troubled manuscript transmission and textual instability: The earliest surviving Greek copy of Jude, the Bodmer composite codex Papyrus 72 (P72), is not a canonical New Testament collection at all, but an early fourth-century private miscellany binding Jude alongside apocryphal and hagiographical tracts, copied by a scribe whose linguistic limitations and theological alterations produced what Kurt and Barbara Aland classified as a “free” text. Nowhere is Jude’s textual instability clearer than at Jude 1:5, where the manuscript and patristic tradition fractures into four competing subjects (“the Lord,” “Jesus” / “Joshua,” “God,” and “God Christ”), and where the recent decision of
NA28andUBS5to replace “the Lord” with “Jesus” illustrates the methodological pitfalls of relying on global algorithmic coherence (CBGM) at the expense of internal stylistic uniformity and local transcriptional probability.
Internal Evidence: Non-Apostolic Posture and Literary Dependence
Before consulting external canon lists or patristic testimonies, the internal evidence of the letter itself establishes that its author did not write as one of the Twelve Apostles. The opening salutation identifies the writer in terms of familial association rather than apostolic commission:
“Jude, a servant of Jesus Christ and brother of James, to those who are called, beloved in God the Father and kept for Jesus Christ:” (Jude 1:1, AICNT)
Had the author been the apostle “Judas of James” (traditionally identified as Judas Thaddaeus in Luke 6:16 and Acts 1:13), claiming the title “apostle of Jesus Christ” would have carried obvious weight in a sharp disciplinary polemic against false teachers. Instead, the writer styles himself simply “a servant of Jesus Christ and brother of James,” identifying himself with Judas, one of the brothers of Jesus mentioned in the Gospels (Matt 13:55; Mark 6:3) and the brother of James, the leader of the Jerusalem church (Acts 15:13; Gal 1:19).2
Even more decisive is the author’s retrospective appeal to the apostles in verses 17–18, where he addresses his readers as a generation looking back on the foundational preaching of the apostles and places himself outside the apostolic college:
“But you, beloved, remember the words which were spoken beforehand by the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ, how they said to you, ‘In the last time there will be scoffers, following after their own ungodly desires.’” (Jude 1:17–18, AICNT)
In both tense and pronoun (“remember the words which were spoken beforehand by the apostles... how they said to you”), the author treats the apostolic preaching as an established past deposit and distinguishes himself from “the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ.” As commentators from Desiderius Erasmus and Martin Luther to James Moffatt, Richard Bauckham, and Bart Ehrman have observed, this retrospective posture is the natural idiom of a post-apostolic writer appealing to an earlier authoritative generation, or of a later writer adopting the persona of James’s brother while looking back on the apostolic era.3 In his critical survey An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, James Moffatt highlighted the tension between Jude’s retrospective appeal to apostolic orthodoxy and its reliance on Jewish apocalyptic legends:
“The writer disclaims originality even for his own warnings; all he requires to do is to remind orthodox Christians (vv. 5, 17) of the principles and prophecies of that faith which they already know (cp. 1 John 2:20–21), a plea for orthodoxy which is curiously bound up with belief in several superstitions drawn from what the author of Titus (1:14) would have sharply denounced as ‘Jewish myths.’ Conservatism involves retrospect, and the epistle looks back upon the apostolic age as (vv. 3, 17) distant and authoritative. These allusions are not to be explained away as if they meant no more than that the apostles were scattered (and therefore out of reach), or that the primitive Palestinian apostles alone are conceived of as dead.” (James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, 1911, p. 346)3
The letter also lacks any specific geographical, ecclesial, or pastoral setting. Unlike the genuine letters of Paul, which address concrete congregations in Rome, Corinth, Galatia, Philippi, and Thessalonica with identifiable coworkers, travel plans, and local circumstances, Jude’s address (“to those who are called”) is entirely generic. Nothing in the text links the tract to a verifiable first-century church or documents how it entered circulation.
Finally, Jude’s literary relationship with 2 Peter confirms that even within the post-apostolic era, Jude’s handling of its sources provoked unease. Modern source criticism has reached a virtual consensus that 2 Peter 2:1–3:3 is literarily dependent upon Jude 4–18.4 What makes this redactional relationship canonically revealing is not merely what the author of 2 Peter borrowed, but what he systematically excised. While incorporating Jude’s denunciations of the false teachers, the fallen angels, Sodom and Gomorrah, and Balaam almost verse by verse, the author of 2 Peter deliberately stripped out Jude’s explicit quotation of 1 Enoch (compare Jude 14–15 with 2 Pet 2:17) and softened Jude’s citation of the dispute between Michael and the devil over the body of Moses from the Assumption of Moses into a vague generalization (compare Jude 9 with 2 Pet 2:11). Even the earliest known Christian writer to use Jude recognized that its overt reliance on pseudepigraphical legends was a liability that needed to be sanitized.
Certification of Second Temple Pseudepigrapha as History and Prophecy
The central internal difficulty of the Epistle of Jude is not that its author was familiar with non-canonical Jewish literature, nor that he employed a passing literary allusion. Rather, Jude explicitly certifies two Second Temple pseudepigraphical compositions as authentic historical reportage and genuine prophetic speech.
The Explicit Citation of 1 Enoch 1:9 in Jude 14–15
In verses 14–15, Jude introduces a verbatim quotation from the Book of Enoch (1 Enoch 1:9) with an unmistakable chronological and prophetic validation:
“Now Enoch, the seventh from Adam, also prophesied about these men, saying, ‘Behold, the Lord came with ten thousands of his holy ones, to execute judgment upon all, and to convict all the ungodly of all their ungodly deeds which they have committed in an ungodly way, and of all the harsh things which ungodly sinners have spoken against him.’” (Jude 1:14–15, AICNT)
Compare Jude’s Greek text with the opening oracle of 1 Enoch 1:9 as preserved in the Ethiopic version, the Greek Codex Panopolitanus (Akhmim fragment), and the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls fragments from Qumran Cave 4 (4Q201 / 4QEna ar I iv 6–9), here rendered in R. H. Charles’s standard translation:
“And behold! He cometh with ten thousands of His holy ones to execute judgement upon all, and to destroy all the ungodly: and to convict all flesh of all the works of their ungodliness which they have ungodly committed, and of all the hard things which ungodly sinners have spoken against Him.” (1 Enoch 1:9, trans. R. H. Charles)5
Three features of Jude’s citation warrant close attention:
- Historical attribution to the antediluvian patriarch: Jude does not say, “As it is written in the book attributed to Enoch,” nor does he frame the quotation as a literary parable. By specifying “Enoch, the seventh from Adam” (ἕβδομος ἀπὸ Ἀδάμ, hebdomos apo Adam, itself a phrase drawn from 1 Enoch 60:8 and 93:3, counting Adam, Seth, Enosh, Kenan, Mahalalel, Jared, and Enoch in Gen 5:3–24), the author affirms that the historical seventh patriarch before the Flood personally uttered these words.
- Prophetic formula (προεφήτευσεν): Jude uses the verb proephēteusen (“prophesied”), the standard early Christian verb for inspired prophetic prediction (compare Matt 11:13; 15:7; 1 Pet 1:10).
- The actual date of 1 Enoch: Archaeological and philological evidence demonstrates beyond dispute that the Book of the Watchers (1 Enoch 1–36), from which Jude quotes 1:9, was not written by an antediluvian patriarch thousands of years before Abraham. It is a composite Jewish apocalyptic work composed in Aramaic during the Hellenistic period, between the third and second centuries BCE.6 Eleven Aramaic manuscripts of 1 Enoch were recovered at Qumran (
4Q201–4Q212), with the oldest copy (4Q201) paleographically dated to the early second century BCE.7
When a writer attributes a Hellenistic pseudepigraphon from the third century BCE to the historical seventh patriarch from Adam and declares that this patriarch “prophesied” those words, the writer has mistaken a Second Temple literary forgery for authentic primordial prophecy.
Dependence on the Watchers Mythology (1 Enoch 6–19) in Jude 6
Jude’s reliance on 1 Enoch is not confined to the direct quotation in verses 14–15. Earlier in the letter, verse 6 summarizes the core myth of the Book of the Watchers (1 Enoch 6–19), an elaborate folkloric expansion of Genesis 6:1–4 in which two hundred rebel angels descend to Mount Hermon, take human wives, sire giant offspring, and are subsequently bound by the archangels in subterranean darkness until the final judgment:
“And the angels who did not keep their own domain, but abandoned their proper dwelling, he has kept in eternal bonds under darkness for the judgment of the great day;” (Jude 1:6, AICNT)
The verbal and conceptual dependence on 1 Enoch 10 is direct and specific:
“And again the Lord said to Raphael: ‘Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein... And on the day of the great judgement he shall be cast into the fire... And when their sons have slain one another, and they have seen the destruction of their beloved ones, bind them fast for seventy generations in the valleys of the earth, till the day of their judgement and of their consummation, till the judgement that is for ever and ever is consummated.’” (1 Enoch 10:4–6, 12, trans. R. H. Charles)8
Nowhere in the Hebrew Bible are rebel angels bound in subterranean chains of darkness awaiting “the judgment of the great day.” Jude presents this Enochic myth directly alongside the biblical accounts of the Exodus (v. 5) and Sodom and Gomorrah (v. 7) as an undifferentiated sequence of historical judgments.
The Assumption of Moses in Jude 9
In verse 9, Jude narrates a confrontation between the archangel Michael and the devil over the corpse of Moses:
“But Michael the archangel, when he disputed with the devil and argued about the body of Moses, did not dare to bring a judgment of blasphemy against him, but said, ‘May the Lord rebuke you!’” (Jude 1:9, AICNT)
The Hebrew Bible records only that Moses died in the land of Moab, that the Lord buried him in a valley opposite Beth-peor, and that “no one knows the place of his burial to this day” (Deut 34:5–6). Where, then, did Jude obtain the story of Michael debating the devil over Moses’ corpse? Early patristic scholars who still had access to the complete Greek text of the Assumption of Moses (also known as the Testament of Moses, a first-century Jewish apocryphon whose surviving sixth-century Milan palimpsest breaks off before the ending) unanimously identified it as Jude’s source.9
Clement of Alexandria (c. 150–215 AD), in his surviving Latin Adumbrationes (comments on the Catholic Epistles), noted on Jude 9:
“‘When Michael, the archangel, disputing with the devil, debated about the body of Moses.’ Here he confirms the assumption of Moses. He is here called Michael, who through an angel near to us debated with the devil.” (Clement of Alexandria, Fragments: Comments on the Epistle of Jude, ANF 2:573)10
Origen of Alexandria (c. 185–253 AD), in On First Principles (De Principiis), explicitly named the little treatise from which Jude drew the scene:
“And in the first place, in the book of Genesis, the serpent is described as having seduced Eve; regarding whom, in the work entitled The Ascension of Moses (a little treatise, of which the Apostle Jude makes mention in his Epistle), the archangel Michael, when disputing with the devil regarding the body of Moses, says that the serpent, being inspired by the devil, was the cause of Adam and Eve’s transgression.” (Origen, De Principiis 3.2.1, ANF 4:328)11
Didymus the Blind (c. 313–398 AD), head of the catechetical school at Alexandria, likewise recorded that Jude’s critics pointed directly to this verse as proof that the epistle relied on apocryphal fabrication.12
The Patristic Dilemma: Tertullian and Augustine on Jude’s Apocryphal Source
Jude’s explicit endorsement of 1 Enoch created an acute theological dilemma for the early church: if Jude is canonical Scripture, must 1 Enoch also be accepted as inspired prophecy? Conversely, if 1 Enoch is a post-diluvian apocryphal fabrication, how can an epistle that certifies it as authentic antediluvian prophecy retain canonical authority?
In early third-century North Africa, Tertullian of Carthage embraced the first horn of the dilemma. In On the Apparel of Women (De Cultu Feminarum 1.3), Tertullian argued that 1 Enoch must be received as Scripture precisely because Jude, together with the Enochic explanation of cosmetic arts and fallen angels, attested it. He took this position even while conceding that the book was excluded from the Jewish scriptural canon (armarium) because no antediluvian book could plausibly have survived Noah’s Flood:
“I am aware that the Scripture of Enoch, which has assigned this order (of action) to angels, is not received by some, because it is not admitted into the Jewish canon either. I suppose they did not think that, having been published before the deluge, it could have safely survived that world-wide calamity, the abolisher of all things. If that is the reason (for rejecting it), let them recall to their memory that Noah, the survivor of the deluge, was the great-grandson of Enoch himself... If (Noah) had not had this (conservative power) by so short a route, there would (still) be this (consideration) to warrant our assertion of (the genuineness of) this Scripture: he could equally have renewed it, under the Spirit’s inspiration, after it had been destroyed by the violence of the deluge, as, after the destruction of Jerusalem by the Babylonian storming of it, every document of the Jewish literature is generally agreed to have been restored through Ezra. But since Enoch in the same Scripture has preached likewise concerning the Lord, nothing at all must be rejected by us which pertains to us; and we read that ‘every Scripture suitable for edification is divinely inspired.’ By the Jews it may now seem to have been rejected for that (very) reason, just like all the other (portions) nearly which tell of Christ... To these considerations is added the fact that Enoch possesses a testimony in the Apostle Jude.” (Tertullian, On the Apparel of Women 1.3, ANF 4:15–16)13
Tertullian’s special pleading, conjecturing either that Noah transmitted 1 Enoch across the Flood or that Enoch’s text was miraculously reconstructed, underscores the historical impossibility that ancient readers immediately recognized.
Two centuries later, Augustine of Hippo rejected Tertullian’s attempt to canonize 1 Enoch, acknowledging that the books circulating under Enoch’s name were filled with fables about giants and lacked any verifiable chain of transmission from antiquity. Yet because the Western synods of Hippo and Carthage had by then included Jude in the canon, Augustine was forced to conjecture that the historical Enoch must have left some divine writings while the books circulating under his name were rightly rejected as apocryphal:
“Let us omit, then, the fables of those scriptures which are called apocryphal, because their obscure origin was unknown to the fathers from whom the authority of the true Scriptures has been transmitted to us by a most certain and well-ascertained succession. For though there is some truth in these apocryphal writings, yet they contain so many false statements, that they have no canonical authority. We cannot deny that Enoch, the seventh from Adam, left some divine writings, for this is asserted by the Apostle Jude in his canonical epistle. But it is not without reason that these writings have no place in that canon of Scripture which was preserved in the temple of the Hebrew people by the diligence of successive priests; for their antiquity brought them under suspicion, and it was impossible to ascertain whether these were his genuine writings, and they were not brought forward as genuine by the persons who were found to have carefully preserved the canonical books by a successive transmission. So that the writings which are produced under his name, and which contain these fables about the giants, saying that their fathers were not men, are properly judged by prudent men to be not genuine; just as many writings are produced by heretics under the names both of other prophets, and, more recently, under the names of the apostles, all of which, after careful examination, have been set apart from canonical authority under the title of Apocrypha.” (Augustine, The City of God 15.23, NPNF 1/2:304–305)14
And again in Book 18 of The City of God, Augustine reiterated why neither Jews nor Christians could receive the Enochic writings as authoritative despite Jude’s citation:
“What of Enoch, the seventh from Adam? Does not the canonical epistle of the Apostle Jude declare that he prophesied? But the writings of these men could not be held as authoritative either among the Jews or us, on account of their too great antiquity, which made it seem needful to regard them with suspicion, lest false things should be set forth instead of true. For some writings which are said to be theirs are quoted by those who, according to their own humor, loosely believe what they please. But the purity of the canon has not admitted these writings, not because the authority of these men who pleased God is rejected, but because they are not believed to be theirs.” (Augustine, The City of God 18.38, NPNF 1/2:383)15
With the discovery of the Aramaic Dead Sea Scrolls at Qumran, Augustine’s harmonization is no longer historically tenable. The exact sentence quoted in Jude 14–15 (1 Enoch 1:9) is an organic part of the opening introduction to the Book of the Watchers (1 Enoch 1–36), the very Hellenistic pseudepigraphon composed in the third or second century BCE that narrates the fables of the Watchers and the giants. It is not an isolated primordial fragment preserved from before the Flood; it is the literary frame of a Second Temple pseudepigraphical apocalypse.
Apologetic Evasions vs. Literary Genre: Paul’s Pagan Poets and Jude’s Prophetic Formula
Defenders of Jude’s canonical status frequently compare Jude 14–15 to the Apostle Paul’s citations of Greek poets in Acts 17:28 (Aratus’s Phaenomena 5 and Cleanthes’ Hymn to Zeus), 1 Corinthians 15:33 (Menander’s comedy Thais), and Titus 1:12 (Epimenides of Crete). The comparison fails on every philological and historical count:
| Feature | Paul’s Classical Citations (Acts 17:28; 1 Cor 15:33; Titus 1:12) | Jude’s Pseudepigraphal Citations (Jude 6, 9, 14–15) |
|---|---|---|
| Source Attribution | Identifies sources accurately as pagan poets or cultural proverbs (“as even some of your own poets have said”). | Attributes a 3rd–2nd century BCE Hellenistic pseudepigraphon to the historical antediluvian patriarch “Enoch, the seventh from Adam.” |
| Rhetorical Function | Uses a known cultural maxim or proverb for ad hominem illustration or ethical common ground. | Certifies 1 Enoch 1:9 as literal eschatological prophecy (προεφήτευσεν) and presents the Watchers myth (1 Enoch 6–19) and Assumption of Moses as literal history alongside the Exodus and Sodom. |
| Literary Honesty | Never validates a pseudonymous forgery as authentic patriarchal history. | Treats pseudonymous Second Temple folklore as genuine historical and prophetic revelation. |
When Paul tells the Athenians on the Areopagus, “as even some of your own poets have said, ‘For we are also his offspring’” (Acts 17:28), he accurately identifies Aratus as a Greek poet and uses a Stoic commonplace to establish a point of contact with his pagan audience. He does not mistake a Hellenistic forgery for a primordial patriarch, nor does he place mythological angelology on the same historical plane as the Exodus.
The Canonical Double Standard: First Clement’s Phoenix vs. Jude’s First Enoch
The anomaly of Jude’s inclusion in the traditional twenty-seven-book canon becomes even sharper when we compare Jude with the earliest surviving non-canonical Christian epistle: First Clement (1 Clement), the letter sent by the church of Rome (traditionally drafted by Clement of Rome) to the church of Corinth around 95–96 AD.
First Clement’s Superior Early Attestation and Ecclesiastical Standing
Measured by every external historical criterion, including date, geographical provenance, second-century attestation, liturgical reading, and inclusion in major biblical codices, First Clement possessed a far stronger claim to early ecclesiastical recognition than the Epistle of Jude:
- Verifiable first-century origin and destination: First Clement was written in Rome around 95–96 AD to the church at Corinth, addressing a specific presbyterial crisis in continuity with Paul’s Corinthian correspondence (1 Clem. 47:1–3). Jude has no known provenance, date, or addressee.
- Continuous second-century attestation: Whereas Jude lacks any clear reference in the Apostolic Fathers or the first eighty years of the second century, First Clement is echoed extensively by Polycarp of Smyrna (c. 110–135 AD), praised by Hegesippus (c. 160 AD), attested as read publicly in the Corinthian church by Dionysius, Bishop of Corinth (c. 170 AD), cited by Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 180 AD) as a powerful witness to apostolic tradition (Against Heresies 3.3.3), and repeatedly quoted by Clement of Alexandria (c. 190–210 AD) under the title of “the Apostle Clement” (Stromata 4.17.105).16 Summarizing the testimony of the Apostolic Fathers (70–120 AD), the Cambridge scholar Brooke Foss Westcott noted the complete absence of Jude:
“Elsewhere in the Apostolic Fathers there are clear traces of a knowledge of the Epistles of St Paul to the Romans, 1 and 2 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, and 1 and 2 Timothy, of the Epistle to the Hebrews, of the Epistle of St James, the first Epistle of St Peter, and the first Epistle of St John. The allusions to the Epistles of St Paul to the Thessalonians, Colossians, to Titus, and Philemon, and to 2 Peter, are very uncertain; and there are, I believe, no coincidences of language with the Epistles of Jude, and 2 and 3 John.” (Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, p. 48)17
- Public liturgical reading across the churches: Eusebius of Caesarea, writing around 325 AD, contrasted the disputed status of Jude with the widespread public reading of First Clement:
“There is extant an epistle of this Clement which is acknowledged to be genuine and is of considerable length and of remarkable merit. He wrote it in the name of the church of Rome to the church of Corinth, when a sedition had arisen in the latter church. We know that this epistle also has been publicly used in a great many churches both in former times and in our own.” (Eusebius, Church History 3.16, NPNF 2/1:147–148)18
- Inclusion in fifth-century New Testament codices and Syriac Bibles: In the fifth-century Codex Alexandrinus (
A/02), one of the four great pandect uncial Bibles of antiquity, First Clement and Second Clement are bound directly inside the New Testament after the Book of Revelation and listed in the codex’s table of contents as part of the New Testament. In the sixth-century Syriac New Testament manuscriptAdd. 14470(University Library, Cambridge), 1–2 Clement are placed immediately after the Catholic Epistles and before the Pauline Epistles, while Didymus the Blind in Alexandria and the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo broader canon likewise reckoned Clement among canonical writings.19
Why Was First Clement Excluded? The Myth of the Arabian Phoenix (1 Clement 25–26)
If First Clement had earlier attestation, clearer provenance, wider liturgical reading, and a place in Codex Alexandrinus, why do modern Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox scholars universally agree that it belongs outside the New Testament canon?
Beyond the fact that Clement wrote in the name of the Roman church rather than as one of the Twelve Apostles, First Clement contains an unmistakable internal marker of sub-apostolic fallibility. In chapters 25–26, Clement solemnly presents the Greco-Egyptian legend of the Phoenix (a mythical bird said to live five hundred years in Arabia, build a nest of frankincense and myrrh upon its death, generate a worm from its decaying flesh that grows wings, and carry its parent’s bones to the altar of the Sun in Heliopolis) as literal biological and historical fact proving the resurrection of the dead:
“Let us consider the marvellous sign which is seen in the regions of the east, that is, in the parts about Arabia. There is a bird, which is named the phoenix. This, being the only one of its kind, liveth for five hundred years; and when it hath now reached the time of its dissolution that it should die, it maketh for itself a coffin of frankincense and myrrh and the other spices, into the which in the fulness of time it entereth, and so it dieth. But, as the flesh rotteth, a certain worm is engendered, which is nurtured from the moisture of the dead creature and putteth forth wings. Then, when it is grown lusty, it taketh up that coffin where are the bones of its parent, and carrying them journeyeth from the country of Arabia even unto Egypt, to the place called the City of the Sun; and in the day time in the sight of all, flying to the altar of the Sun, it layeth them thereupon; and this done, it setteth forth to return. So the priests examine the registers of the times, and they find that it hath come when the five hundredth year is completed. Do we then think it to be a great and marvellous thing, if the Creator of the universe shall bring about the resurrection of them that have served Him with holiness in the assurance of a good faith, seeing that He showeth to us even by a bird the magnificence of His promise?” (1 Clement 25:1–26:1, trans. J. B. Lightfoot, vol. 2, p. 285)20
In sharing this credulous belief in the Phoenix, Clement was repeating a widespread natural-history error of the Greco-Roman world endorsed by Herodotus (Histories 2.73), Pliny the Elder (Natural History 10.2), Tacitus (Annals 6.28), and later echoed by Tertullian (On the Resurrection of the Flesh 13) and Cyril of Jerusalem (Catechetical Lectures 18.8). Yet later Christian scholars recognized that an inspired canonical document cannot certify a pagan mythological fable as a historical work of the Creator. In the ninth century, Patriarch Photius of Constantinople highlighted this exact defect in his critical review of First Clement, as J. B. Lightfoot noted in his commentary:
“Nevertheless, in this epistle a few things may be found worthy of censure: first, that he asserts there are other worlds beyond the ocean; second, that he introduces the story of the phoenix as a true fact...” (Photius of Constantinople, Bibliotheca, Codex 126, author’s trans.; cf. J. B. Lightfoot, S. Clement of Rome, vol. 2, pp. 62, 84)21
The Inconsistency Exposed
Here the canonical double standard stands in full view. Every scholar recognizes that First Clement’s endorsement of the Arabian Phoenix as a literal biological sign demonstrates that Clement, however devout and close to the apostolic age, was a fallible post-apostolic writer capable of mistaking popular ancient folklore for factual reality.
Yet what First Clement 25–26 does with Greco-Roman natural folklore, Jude 6, 9, and 14–15 does with Second Temple Jewish folklore:
- First Clement certifies the Arabian Phoenix as literal biological fact; Jude certifies the Enochic Watchers myth (1 Enoch 6–19), the dispute over Moses’ corpse (Assumption of Moses), and a third-century BCE Hellenistic apocalypse (1 Enoch 1:9) as literal historical fact and authentic antediluvian prophecy.
- Both works were written by non-apostles who explicitly distinguish themselves from the original apostles (1 Clem. 42, 44, 47; Jude 1, 17–18).
- Of the two, First Clement actually possesses vastly stronger second-century attestation and a known historical setting, whereas Jude was widely rejected across the ancient church precisely because of its apocryphal citations.
To exclude First Clement while elevating Jude to foundational canonical status is a clear breach of historical consistency. Both writings belong in the same category of early, historically informative, but non-canonical post-apostolic literature.
Contested Reception in the Early Church and the Reformation (Antilegomena)
Far from enjoying unanimous recognition in antiquity, the Epistle of Jude was one of the most persistently contested writings in Christian history. Across North Africa, Egypt, Palestine, Syria, Asia Minor, and sixteenth-century Europe, church fathers, canon lists, and translators either expressed explicit doubt about Jude or excluded it outright.
Origen of Alexandria: “If Indeed One Were to Accept the Epistle of Jude”
Although Origen of Alexandria (c. 185–253 AD) admired Jude’s compact phrasing and cited it in several works, he was acutely aware that its canonical standing was disputed across the churches. When quoting Jude 1 in his Commentary on Matthew (10.17), Origen praised the epistle as “filled with vigorous words of heavenly grace,” yet seven books later in the very same commentary (17.30), when appealing to Jude 6 alongside Paul’s epistles, he added an explicit canonical hedge:
“And if indeed one were to accept the Epistle of Jude, let him consider what will follow from the statement: ‘And the angels who did not keep their own principality, but abandoned their proper dwelling, he has kept in eternal chains under darkness until the judgment of the great day.’” (Origen, Commentary on Matthew 17.30, author’s trans.; cf. Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, p. 369)22
Origen does not attach “if indeed one were to accept” (Εἰ δὲ καὶ τὴν Ἰούδα προσίετό τις ἐπιστολήν) to Luke, Acts, Romans, or 1 Corinthians. That conditional clause is the unmistakable signature of a disputed book whose authority could not be assumed in debate.
Eusebius of Caesarea: Classified Among the Antilegomena
In his Church History (c. 325 AD), Eusebius of Caesarea, who had access to the great library of Pamphilus and Origen at Caesarea, twice recorded Jude’s contested standing. At the conclusion of Book 2, reviewing the origin of the seven so-called Catholic Epistles, Eusebius wrote:
“These things are recorded in regard to James, who is said to be the author of the first of the so-called catholic epistles. But it is to be observed that it is disputed; at least, not many of the ancients have mentioned it, as is the case likewise with the epistle that bears the name of Jude, which is also one of the seven so-called catholic epistles. Nevertheless we know that these also, with the rest, have been read publicly in very many churches.” (Eusebius, Church History 2.23.25, NPNF 2/1:128)23
In his formal canonical catalogue in Book 3, Chapter 25, Eusebius excluded Jude from the universally acknowledged writings (homologoumena) and placed it squarely among the disputed writings (antilegomena):
“Among the disputed writings, which are nevertheless recognized by many, are extant the so-called epistle of James and that of Jude, also the second epistle of Peter, and those that are called the second and third of John, whether they belong to the evangelist or to another person of the same name.” (Eusebius, Church History 3.25.3, NPNF 2/1:156)24
Didymus the Blind and Jerome: Rejected Because It Quotes the Apocryphal Book of Enoch
Why did so many early Christians refuse to accept Jude? Two fourth-century patristic scholars state the reason in plain terms. In his Commentary on Jude (Enarratio in Epistolam Judae), Didymus the Blind (c. 313–398 AD) recorded that opponents of the epistle challenged its canonical authority specifically because of its reliance on apocryphal tradition regarding Moses’ body in verse 9:
“In reference to the content of this passage, some contradict the present Epistle and say that it is not canonical, because what is written here about the body of Moses is found nowhere in the ancient Scriptures, but is handed down in an apocryphal work.” (Didymus the Blind, Enarratio in Epistolam Judae, on Jude 9, author’s trans.)25
Even more famous is the testimony of Jerome (c. 347–420 AD), compiler of the Latin Vulgate. In chapter 4 of his biographical catalogue Lives of Illustrious Men (De Viris Illustribus, 392–393 AD), Jerome acknowledged that Jude was “rejected by many” (a plerisque reicitur) for the exact reason modern textual and canonical scholars highlight today:
“Jude the brother of James, left a short epistle which is reckoned among the seven catholic epistles, and because in it he quotes from the apocryphal book of Enoch it is rejected by many. Nevertheless by age and use it has gained authority and is reckoned among the Holy Scriptures.” (Jerome, Lives of Illustrious Men 4, NPNF 2/3:362)26
Jerome’s candid admission exposes the mechanism by which Jude eventually entered the fourth-century Western canon: not because the historical objection to its apocryphal source was ever refuted, but because sheer custom (“by age and use,” vetustate iam et usu) overrode the critical objection.
Regional Exclusions: North Africa, Antioch, Asia Minor, and the Syriac Peshitta
The patristic reservations recorded by Origen, Eusebius, Didymus, and Jerome correspond directly to regional canon lists and biblical translations that omitted Jude altogether:
- The North African Cheltenham List (Mommsen Catalogue, c. 360 AD): This stichometric list of the Old and New Testaments from fourth-century North Africa enumerates the four Gospels, thirteen epistles of Paul, Acts, Revelation, three epistles of John, and two of Peter, while completely omitting James, Jude, and Hebrews.27
- The School of Antioch (John Chrysostom and Theodore of Mopsuestia): John Chrysostom (c. 347–407 AD), the most prolific Greek homilist of antiquity, makes approximately 11,000 quotations from the New Testament across his vast corpus without a single quotation from Jude, 2 Peter, 2–3 John, or Revelation. His contemporary Theodore of Mopsuestia (c. 350–428 AD) rejected the minor Catholic Epistles outright, and Severus of Antioch (d. 538 AD) likewise excluded Jude.28
- Asia Minor (Amphilochius of Iconium, c. 395 AD): Writing his metrical catalogue Iambi ad Seleucum, Amphilochius noted regarding the Catholic Epistles: “Some say seven must be received, others say only three should be accepted: one of James, one of Peter, and one of John.”29
- The Syriac Peshitta and the Church of the East: The earliest Syriac canon (represented by the fourth-century Doctrine of Addai and Aphrahat) contained no Catholic Epistles at all. When the standard Syriac Peshitta New Testament was established in the early fifth century, it admitted only three Catholic Epistles (James, 1 Peter, and 1 John) and permanently excluded Jude, 2 Peter, 2–3 John, and Revelation, resulting in a twenty-two-book New Testament that remains the official canon of the Assyrian Church of the East to the present day.30 In the sixth century, Junilius Africanus (c. 551 AD), transmitting the teaching of Paul of Nisibis from the Syrian school at Nisibis in his Instituta Regularia Divinae Legis (1.6–7), explicitly placed Jude, 2 Peter, James, 2–3 John, and Revelation in a separate category of “middle authority” (mediae auctoritatis) added by only some to the foundational canon.31
Summarizing this divided patristic record, James Moffatt observed:
“By the end of the second century the homily was accepted as canonical and apostolic in Alexandria (Clement, Origen), Africa (Tertullian), and Rome (Murat. Canon); but the very terms and context in which it is mentioned in the Mur. Canon and even in Origen (in Matt. t. 17:30) indicate that its reception was far from being unanimous; and this is corroborated by its absence subsequently from the writings of the Antioch school and the Syriac vulgate. The suspicions (Eus. H. E. 2:23. 25) which thus hindered its entrance into certain circles of the church, as one of the ἀντιλεγόμενα, were due not to critical scruples so much as to the hesitation aroused by the source and character of its apocryphal citations (so Jerome, de uir. illustr. 4). Its unpopularity in the African churches, to judge from Cyprian’s lack of reference to it and from other data, and its failure to win acceptance in the school of Antioch, rendered its ecclesiastical career as precarious and chequered as that of several of the other ‘catholic epistles.’” (James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, 1911, pp. 352–353)28
The Sixteenth-Century Reassessment: Luther, Erasmus, Cardinal Cajetan, and Oecolampadius
When the revival of Greek philology and patristic studies in the sixteenth century allowed European scholars to re-examine the New Testament canon behind the late medieval Latin Vulgate, the ancient objections to Jude immediately resurfaced across both Protestant and Roman Catholic scholarship.
In his 1522 Preface to the Epistles of St. James and St. Jude in the Septembertestament, Martin Luther removed Hebrews, James, Jude, and Revelation from the numbered sequence of his German New Testament, placing them in an unnumbered appendix after what he called “the true and certain Capital-books of the New Testament; for these four have been regarded in former times in a different light.”32 Luther laid out four specific, text-based arguments explaining why Jude cannot be reckoned among the foundational books that establish Christian doctrine:
“Concerning the Epistle of St. Jude, no one can deny that it is an extract or copy of St. Peter’s second epistle, so very like it are all the words. He also speaks of the apostles like a disciple who comes long after them and cites sayings and incidents that are found nowhere else in the Scriptures. This moved the ancient fathers to exclude this epistle from the main body of the Scriptures. Moreover, the Apostle Jude did not go to Greek-speaking lands, but to Persia, as it is said, so that he did not write Greek. Therefore, although I value this book, it is an epistle that need not be counted among the chief books which are supposed to lay the foundations of faith.” (Martin Luther, Preface to the Epistles of St. James and St. Jude, 1522; cf. Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, p. 491, and Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 6, pp. 35–36)32
Even though modern source criticism reverses the direction of literary dependence between Jude and 2 Peter (holding that 2 Peter 2 expanded Jude rather than Jude abbreviating 2 Peter), Luther’s remaining observations are incisive: (1) Jude 17–18 speaks of the apostles as a disciple coming long after them; (2) Jude cites sayings and incidents (1 Enoch and the Assumption of Moses) found nowhere in canonical Scripture; and (3) these exact defects moved the ancient church fathers to exclude the epistle from the primary Scriptures.
Luther was not alone. Six years earlier, in his landmark Annotationes in Novum Testamentum (1516), the Dutch humanist Desiderius Erasmus called attention to Jerome’s testimony that Jude was rejected by many on account of its apocryphal Enoch citation.33 Among the Swiss Reformers at Basel, Johannes Oecolampadius wrote on behalf of his colleagues in 1530 that while they read the seven Catholic Epistles and the Apocalypse, “we do not compare the Apocalypse, the Epistles of James, and Jude, and 2 Peter and 2, 3 John with the rest.”34 And on the Roman Catholic side, prior to the Council of Trent’s dogmatic decree of April 8, 1546, Thomas de Vio (Cardinal Cajetan), the foremost Thomistic theologian of the sixteenth century, appealed directly to Jerome to place Jude, James, and 2–3 John in a subordinate rank:
“In like manner he [Cardinal Caietan] quotes Jerome for the doubts entertained as to the authority of St James, 2 Peter, 2 and 3 John, and St Jude. Of the three last he expressly says that ‘they are of less authority than those which are certainly Holy Scripture.’” (Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, p. 483)34
Textual Criticism of Jude, Part I: The Bodmer Miscellany (P72) and the Habits of Its Scribe
When we turn from canonical history to the Greek manuscript transmission of Jude, the evidence becomes even more problematic. Because Jude was so brief, contested, and liturgically neglected, its early manuscript base is extraordinarily narrow. And when we examine the single earliest surviving Greek copy of the complete epistle, Papyrus 72 (P72, Papyrus Bodmer VII–VIII), both its physical codicology and the work of its copyist reveal a text transmitted in an apocryphal environment by an erratic hand.
Codicological Context: An Early Fourth-Century Apocryphal Miscellany
Discovered in Upper Egypt in 1952 as part of the Dishna / Bodmer find and published by Michel Testuz in 1959, Papyrus 72 (P72) is paleographically dated to the late third or early fourth century (c. 300–350 AD; the Münster Kurzgefasste Liste assigns III/IV, while Eric G. Turner, Pasquale Orsini, Willy Clarysse, and Brent Nongbri emphasize the early fourth-century codicological and paleographical features of the composite book).35
Popular apologetic treatments frequently cite P72 as if it were an early “New Testament manuscript” testifying to the canonical status of Jude and 1–2 Peter. In reality, P72 is merely the modern Gregory-Aland catalogue number assigned to the three New Testament tracts extracted from a nine-section (eleven-text) composite papyrus codex (the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex, measuring roughly 16 × 14.5 cm), bound together in antiquity and sharing overlapping scribal hands, pagination patterns, and a common liturgical or ascetic compilation history.36 The complete contents of this composite codex in their physical order are:
- The Nativity of Mary (Protevangelium of James, a second-century infancy apocryphon)
- The Apocryphal Correspondence of Paul and the Corinthians (3 Corinthians, extracted from the apocryphal Acts of Paul)
- The Eleventh Ode of Solomon (an early Christian pseudepigraphical ode)
- The Epistle of Jude (
P.Bodmer VII, paginated pp.1–68continuously with the preceding tracts) - Melito of Sardis’s Homily on the Passover
- A Fragment of a Christian Hymn
- The Apology of Phileas (a martyr act of Phileas, Bishop of Thmuis, who was executed under Diocletian c. 304–307 AD, providing a firm terminus post quem for the final compilation of the codex in the fourth century)
- Psalms 33 and 34 (LXX)
- First and Second Peter (
P.Bodmer VIII)
Notice two critical codicological facts documented by Tommy Wasserman in his specialized studies of the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex and the text of Jude:37
First, the inclusion of the Apology of Phileas (martyred c. 304–307 AD) inside the composite codex confirms that the collection was assembled in the early fourth century, more than two hundred years after the apostolic age.
Second, within the codex, Jude is not even grouped physically with 1 and 2 Peter. As Wasserman has shown, whereas Scribe A copied The Nativity of Mary, Scribe B copied the Apocryphal Correspondence of Paul and the Corinthians (3 Corinthians), the Eleventh Ode of Solomon, and the Epistle of Jude as the fourth tract in a continuous pagination sequence (pp. 1–68) shared with those three apocryphal works, whereas 1 and 2 Peter—likewise copied by Scribe B on an originally separate pagination series—were bound at the very end of the codex, separated from Jude by four non-biblical texts.38 Far from proving that Jude circulated inside a settled, canonical New Testament collection, the earliest surviving manuscript of Jude physically places it inside a private fourth-century Egyptian miscellany sandwiched between the Protevangelium of James, 3 Corinthians, the Odes of Solomon, and fourth-century hagiography.
The Scribe of P72: Carelessness, Coptic Interference, and “Free” Transmission
What of the textual quality of Jude inside P72? Every major papyrologist and textual critic who has examined Scribe B’s copying of Jude and 1–2 Peter in P72 has remarked on the copyist’s imperfect command of Greek, high rate of mechanical blunders, and unusual freedom in altering the text.
In his landmark study Scribal Habits in Early Greek New Testament Papyri (2008), James R. Royse analyzed the singular readings and corrections of the six major early extensive papyri (P45, P46, P47, P66, P72, and P75). Evaluating P72 across chapter 8 of his monograph, Royse documented that Greek was evidently not the copyist’s native language—as shown by pervasive Coptic phonetic interference, vowel and consonant interchanges, and erratic orthography—and that the manuscript exhibits a remarkably high proportion of orthographic singulars, unintelligible nonsense readings, grammatical slips, and hasty self-corrections (52 in scribendo corrections out of 86 total corrections).39
Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, one of the editors of the UBS Greek New Testament committee who published a specialized transcription and study of P.Bodmer VIII (1–2 Peter in P72), delivered an equally blunt assessment of the copyist, observing that “the true and proper errors of the scribe are rather numerous and demonstrate a rather mediocre diligence and a quite uncertain knowledge of the Greek language.”40
Earlier, in his 1965 monograph P72 and the Codex Vaticanus, Sakae Kubo demonstrated that although the underlying exemplar from which P72 was copied shared a genuine Alexandrian ancestor with Codex Vaticanus (B), the copyist of P72 introduced so many careless singular variants, individualistic substitutions, omissions, and harmonizations that those singular readings had to be systematically isolated and set aside before the manuscript’s underlying textual affinity with Vaticanus could be properly measured.41
Even more striking is the disparity in textual quality within P72 between 1–2 Peter and Jude. In their standard reference manual The Text of the New Testament, Kurt Aland and Barbara Aland—even while assigning P72 to Category I because of its early date—distinguished sharply between its two parts, characterizing 1 and 2 Peter as “at least normal text” but classifying Jude as a “free text, both with certain peculiarities.”42
Concrete Examples of P72’s Corruptions and Theological Alterations in Jude
A brief inspection of P72’s text across Jude’s twenty-five verses, including the exact lines surrounding Jude 5, shows why the Alands labeled its text of Jude “free” and why its uncorroborated readings cannot be trusted:
| Locus | Standard Critical Text (NA27 / AICNT) | Reading of P72 | Nature of Scribal Corruption |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jude 1:4 | τὴν τοῦ θεοῦ ἡμῶν χάριτα μετατιθέντες εἰς ἀσέλγειαν (“turning the grace of our God into sensuality”) | Inserts καὶ τὸν νόμον ἡμῶν (τὴν τοῦ θεοῦ ἡμῶν χάριτα καὶ τὸν νόμον ἡμῶν..., “turning the grace of our God and our law into sensuality”) | Singular explanatory expansion found in no other Greek manuscript in the world. |
| Jude 1:5a | εἰδότας ὑμᾶς πάντα (“though you know all things”) | εἰδότας ὑμᾶς πάντα ὅτι (misplacing ὅτι and altering syntax) | Syntactic confusion and transposition. |
| Jude 1:5b | λαὸν ἐκ γῆς Αἰγύπτου σώσας τὸ δεύτερον τοὺς μὴ πιστεύσαντας ἀπώλεσεν | Writes ΕΓ ΓΗΣ ΕΓΥΠΤΟΥ (phonetic consonant assimilation ἐκ → ἐγ and vowel confusion Αἰγύπτου → Ἐγύπτου), substitutes singular ΘΣ ΧΣ (θεὸς Χριστός, “God Christ”) as subject, and scrambles the participle ΠΙΣΤΕΥΣΑΝΤΕΣ (nominative plural instead of accusative πιστεύσαντας) | Triple mechanical blunder plus singular theological conflation (ΘΣ ΧΣ) in a single sentence. |
| Jude 1:24–25 | Τῷ δὲ δυναμένῳ φυλάξαι ὑμᾶς ἀπταίστους καὶ στῆσαι κατενώπιον τῆς δόξης αὐτοῦ... | Rewrites the entire closing doxology as Τῷ δὲ δυναμένῳ ὑμᾶς στηρίξαι ἄσπιλους... (“Now to him who is able to establish you spotless...”), omitting σωτῆρι ἡμῶν διὰ Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν and πρὸ παντὸς τοῦ αἰῶνος | Extensive liturgical harmonization to the doxology of Romans 16:25 (Τῷ δὲ δυναμένῳ ὑμᾶς στηρίξαι) and 2 Peter 3:14 (ἄσπιλοι). |
Furthermore, building on Bart D. Ehrman’s analysis of early Christological alterations, Tommy Wasserman has highlighted how Scribe B of P72 modified divine titles at three separate points across the three Catholic Epistles in his codex in ways that heighten the identification of Christ with θεός (“God”): in 1 Peter 5:1 he replaces “the sufferings of Christ” (τῶν τοῦ Χριστοῦ παθημάτων) with “the sufferings of God” (τῶν τοῦ θεοῦ παθημάτων); in 2 Peter 1:2 he omits the conjunction καί so that “knowledge of God and of Jesus our Lord” reads appositionally as “knowledge of God, Jesus our Lord”; and in Jude 5 he writes the strictly singular conflation “God Christ” (θεὸς Χριστός).43
When a manuscript is physically an early fourth-century miscellany of apocryphal and hagiographical tracts, copied by a scribe whose command of Greek grammar was defective and who demonstrably rewrote three divine titles across his codex, it provides a vivid window into the fluid, poorly controlled textual environment in which the Epistle of Jude was transmitted.
Textual Criticism of Jude, Part II: The Jude 1:5 Variant Nexus and the Flawed NA28 / UBS5 Reversal
Nowhere do the textual instabilities of Jude converge more dramatically than in Jude 1:5. In his opening triad of historical warnings (vv. 5–7: the wilderness generation after the Exodus, the rebellious angels of 1 Enoch, and the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah), the author reminds his readers that the one who saved a people out of the land of Egypt afterward destroyed those who did not believe. Yet when we consult the surviving Greek manuscripts, ancient versions, and Church Fathers to determine who is named as the subject of the participle σώσας (“having saved”) and the verb ἀπώλεσεν (“destroyed”), the manuscript tradition splinters into four major competing readings, alongside multiple word-order permutations of the adverb ἅπαξ (“once for all”):
The Four Competing Subjects of Jude 1:5
| Reading (Greek & Nomina Sacra) | Meaning | Principal Manuscript, Versional, and Patristic Witnesses | Critical Editions Printing This Text |
|---|---|---|---|
1. [ὁ] κύριος (Ο ΚΣ / ΚΣ) | “the Lord” | Codex Sinaiticus (ℵ / 01, 4th c.), Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus (C* / 04, 5th c., original hand), Codex Athous Lavrensis (Ψ / 044), minuscules 307, 436, 453, 614, 1505, 2412, the entire Byzantine Majority Text (𝔐) (K, L, P, 049, 056, 0142), Syriac Philoxenian / Harklean (syr^{ph, h}), and Old Latin witnesses | Tischendorf (8th ed., 1872), Westcott & Hort (1881, margin/text interplay), Nestle-Aland (NA26–NA27, 1979–1993), UBS Greek New Testament (UBS1–UBS4, 1966–1993), SBLGNT (2010, margin), AICNT (2024–2026) |
2. Ἰησοῦς (Ο ΙΣ / ΙΣ) | “Jesus” (or “Joshua”) | Codex Vaticanus (B / 03, 4th c.), Codex Alexandrinus (A / 02, 5th c.), minuscules 33, 81, 322, 323, 424^c, 665, 1241, 1739, 1881, 2298, 2344, Latin Vulgate (vg), Coptic (cop^{sa, bo}), Ethiopic (eth), Origen (Latin translation of Hom. in Num.), Cyril of Alexandria, Jerome (Adv. Jov. 1.21, explicitly interpreting Ἰησοῦς as Joshua) | Lachmann (1850), Westcott & Hort (1881, with suspicion of primitive error), Editio Critica Maior (ECM, 1997/2013), Nestle-Aland NA28 (2012), UBS UBS5 (2014), SBLGNT (2010), Tyndale House GNT (2017) |
3. ὁ θεός (Ο ΘΣ / ΘΣ) | “God” | Clement of Alexandria (Paedagogus 3.8.44, c. 200 AD, the earliest extant witness by more than a century), Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus (C^2, corrector), minuscules 442, 621, 1243, 1846, Byzantine lectionaries (Lect), Armenian (arm), Georgian, Slavonic (slav^{ms}), Lucifer of Cagliari (4th c.) | Recorded in all major critical apparatuses as the earliest patristic reading |
4. θεὸς Χριστός (ΘΣ ΧΣ) | “God Christ” | Papyrus 72 (P72, early 4th c., strictly singular, unattested in any other Greek manuscript, version, or father) | Rejected by all critical editions as a scribal conflation or theological alteration |
The Earliest Extant Witness (c. 200 AD): Clement of Alexandria Reads “God” (ὁ θεός) and “the Lord God”
Discussions of Jude 5 often begin with fourth-century manuscripts (P72, Vaticanus, Sinaiticus) while overlooking the single earliest Greek witness to the verse in existence. Around 200 AD, more than a century before P72, Codex Vaticanus, or Codex Sinaiticus were copied, Clement of Alexandria quoted Jude 5–6 in Book 3, Chapter 8 of his Paedagogus (The Instructor). In Clement’s Greek text, the subject of Jude 5 is neither “Jesus” nor “God Christ,” but ὁ θεός (“God”):
“‘For I would have you know,’ says Jude, ‘that God, having once saved His people from the land of Egypt, afterwards destroyed them that believed not; and the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, He hath reserved to the judgment of the great day, in everlasting chains under darkness of the savage angels.’” (Clement of Alexandria, The Instructor (Paedagogus) 3.8, ANF 2:282)44
Moreover, in his surviving Latin Comments on the Epistle of Jude (Adumbrationes), Clement’s lemma for Jude 5 reads “the Lord God” (Dominus Deus):
“‘For the Lord God,’ he says, ‘who once delivered a people out of Egypt, afterward destroyed them that believed not;’ that is, through Moses.” (Clement of Alexandria, Fragments: Comments on the Epistle of Jude, ANF 2:573)44
Clement’s two citations prove two vital historical points:
- In Alexandria itself around the year 200 AD, the very geographical region that later produced
P72and Codex Vaticanus, the earliest documented Greek text of Jude 5 readὁ θεός(“God”) or “the Lord God,” neverἸησοῦς. - This early Alexandrian reading (
ὁ θεός=Ο ΘΣ) directly explains how the erratic scribe ofP72a century later produced his singular conflationθεὸς Χριστός(ΘΣ ΧΣ): working from an exemplar or memory ofΘΣ(“God”) alongside a Christological gloss (ΧΣ), the scribe ofP72combined them intoΘΣ ΧΣ.
How Ancient Readers Understood Ἰησοῦς in Jude 5: Joshua Son of Nun (Ἰησοῦς = Yehoshua)
What of the manuscripts (A, B, 33, 81, 1739, vg) that read Ἰησοῦς (Latin Iesus)? In Koine Greek, both in the Septuagint (LXX) and throughout the New Testament, the Greek name Ἰησοῦς (Iēsous) is the exact, standard spelling of the Hebrew name Joshua (Yehoshua), the son of Nun who led the Israelites through the wilderness and into Canaan (compare Acts 7:45 and Hebrews 4:8, where the Greek text reads Ἰησοῦς and modern translations render “Joshua”).
Furthermore, in the wilderness rebellion narrated in Numbers 14, the two faithful spies who stood against the unbelieving Israelites who perished in the desert were Caleb and Joshua (Ἰησοῦς in the LXX), and it was Joshua who led the surviving people out of the wilderness into the Promised Land while the unbelievers died in the desert (Num 14:6–38; 26:65).
Crucially, we do not have to guess whether fourth-century readers who had Ἰησοῦς (Iesus) in their copies of Jude 5 connected it with Joshua the son of Nun. Two passages from Jerome, compiler of the Latin Vulgate that reads Iesus at Jude 5, document this exact interpretation. First, in 386 AD, writing Letter XLVI (in the name of Paula and Eustochium to Marcella, § 7), Jerome quoted Jude 5–6 and explicitly remarked on the tendency of readers to understand Iesus in verse 5 as Joshua the son of Nun:
“Which also is written in the Epistle of Jude, ‘I will therefore put you in remembrance, though ye once knew this, how that Jesus, having saved the people out of the land of Egypt, afterward destroyed them that believed not.’ And, lest you should fancy Joshua the son of Nun to be meant, the passage goes on thus: ‘And the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day.’” (Jerome, Letter XLVI 7, NPNF 2/6:63)45
Then, just seven years later in 393 AD, in Against Jovinianus (Adversus Jovinianum 1.21), Jerome himself adopted that very reading and cited Jude 5 directly of Joshua the son of Nun in contrast to Moses:
“I must not linger over Moses when my purpose is at full speed to lightly touch on each topic and to sketch the outline of a proper knowledge of my subject. I will pass to Joshua the son of Nun, who was previously called Ause, or better, as in the Hebrew, Osee, that is, Saviour. For he, according to the epistle of Jude, saved the people of Israel and led them forth out of Egypt, and brought them into the land of promise.” (Jerome, Against Jovinianus 1.21, NPNF 2/6:361–362)45
Notice the significance of Jerome’s two statements: not only was taking Iesus (Ἰησοῦς) in Jude 5 as Joshua the son of Nun so widespread in the fourth century that Jerome had to address it in 386 AD, but by 393 AD the translator of the Latin Vulgate himself cited Jude 5 as referring to Joshua the son of Nun. In modern scholarship, Allen Wikgren (one of the five editors of the UBS Greek New Testament committee) likewise argued in a dedicated study on Jude 5 that the variant Ἰησοῦς originated or was understood in connection with Joshua (Iēsous), the hero of the Exodus-wilderness narrative.46
The Verdict of UBS1–UBS4 and NA26–NA27: Why the Committee Majority Printed [ὁ] κύριος
For most of the twentieth century, across the first four editions of the United Bible Societies’ Greek New Testament (UBS1–UBS4, 1966–1993) and the 26th and 27th editions of Nestle-Aland (NA26–NA27, 1979–1993), a three-to-two majority of the international editorial committee (Kurt Aland, Matthew Black, and Carlo Maria Martini, over the dissent of Bruce M. Metzger and Allen Wikgren) rejected Ἰησοῦς and printed [ὁ] κύριος (“the Lord,” with a {D} rating) in the main text of Jude 5.
In A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed., 1994, pp. 657–658), Bruce M. Metzger recorded both the reasoning of the committee majority and the signed dissenting note authored by himself and Allen Wikgren. Notwithstanding the strong external attestation for Ἰησοῦς (A, B, 33, 81, 322, 323, 424^c, 665, 1241, 1739, 1881, 2298, 2344, vg, cop^{sa, bo}, eth, Origen, Cyril, Jerome, and Bede), the majority judged that Ἰησοῦς was “difficult to the point of impossibility,” accounting for its rise through transcriptional oversight in Greek or Coptic nomina sacra (such as Coptic ΚΧ being misread as ΙΧ, alongside Greek ΚΣ / ΙΣ), reinforced either by the immediately preceding mention of Ἰησοῦν Χριστόν at the close of verse 4 or by typological association with Joshua (Ἰησοῦς). Observing that P72’s singular reading θεὸς Χριστός reflected the theological proclivity of its scribe (comparing 1 Pet 5:1) and that κύριος, Ἰησοῦς, and θεός were all circulating widely by the end of the fourth century, the majority adopted [ὁ] κύριος (ℵ, C*, Ψ, 307, 436, 453, 614, 1505, 2412, Byz, Lect, syr^{ph, h}) as the least unsatisfactory reading, whereas Metzger and Wikgren dissented on p. 658 on the ground that “Critical principles seem to require the adoption of Ἰησοῦς, which admittedly is the best attested reading among Greek and versional witnesses.”47
Even Fenton John Anthony Hort (1881), although printing Ἰησοῦς because of his programmatic reliance on Codex Vaticanus (B), was so troubled by the internal incongruity of Ἰησοῦς in Jude 5 that he wrote a lengthy appendix note arguing that Ἰησοῦς was a primitive scribal blunder for an original ΟΤΙ Ο (“that He who saved...”), a conjecture endorsed in 1901 by P. W. Schmiedel and Orello Cone in the Encyclopaedia Biblica.48
Why Did NA28 (2012) and UBS5 (2014) Switch to Ἰησοῦς? A Critique of the CBGM Decision
In 2012 (NA28) and 2014 (UBS5), the text of the Catholic Epistles was revised to adopt the reconstruction of the Münster Institute’s Editio Critica Maior (ECM), which introduced a new computer-assisted methodology known as the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM), developed by Gerd Mink.49 As one of the thirty-four textual changes introduced in the Catholic Epistles of NA28/UBS5, the editors removed [ὁ] κύριος at Jude 5 and printed Ἰησοῦς.
Why did the ECM / NA28 / UBS5 editors reverse the judgment of NA26–NA27 and UBS1–UBS4, and why does that reversal fail under rigorous textual-critical scrutiny?
The ECM editors appealed to two primary considerations: (1) global genealogical coherence calculated by the CBGM software (because Codices A, B, and minuscule 1739 rank among the highest-scoring witnesses across the Catholic Epistles as a whole, the CBGM treats their agreement at Jude 5 as genealogically weighty); and (2) a mechanical application of the maxim lectio difficilior potior (“the more difficult reading is to be preferred”), arguing that since “Jesus” saving the people out of Egypt is unexpected, scribes must have changed a difficult Ἰησοῦς into the easier κύριος or θεός.
When examined closely, however, both pillars of the NA28/UBS5 decision collapse:
1. Unbroken Internal Authorial Style: Jude Writes Ἰησοῦς Χριστός 6 out of 6 Times and Never Bare Ἰησοῦς
The first fundamental flaw in the NA28/UBS5 decision is that it violates one of the most rigid, unbroken stylistic patterns in the entire New Testament. Across Jude’s twenty-five verses, the author refers to Jesus six undisputed times, and in every single instance (6 for 6, or 100%) he uses the full compound designation Ἰησοῦς Χριστός (“Jesus Christ”), never once the bare name Ἰησοῦς:
- Jude 1:1a:
Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ δοῦλος(“a servant of Jesus Christ”) - Jude 1:1b:
Ἰησοῦ Χριστῷ τετηρημένοις(“kept for Jesus Christ”) - Jude 1:4:
τὸν μόνον δεσπότην καὶ κύριον ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦν Χριστὸν ἀρνούμενοι(“denying our only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ”) - Jude 1:17:
τῶν ἀποστόλων τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ(“the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ”) - Jude 1:21:
τὸ ἔλεος τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ(“the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ”) - Jude 1:25:
διὰ Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν(“through Jesus Christ our Lord”)
Conversely, whenever the author of Jude refers to divine judgment or prophetic action in Old Testament or Enochic narratives, his standard noun is κύριος (“the Lord”):
- Jude 1:9:
Ἐπιτιμήσαι σοι κύριος(“May the Lord rebuke you!”) - Jude 1:14:
Ἰδοὺ ἦλθεν κύριος ἐν ἁγίαις μυριάσιν αὐτοῦ(“Behold, the Lord came with ten thousands of his holy ones”)
In classical textual criticism (as Hort, J. K. Elliott, and practitioners of thoroughgoing and reasoned eclecticism emphasized), intrinsic probability asks what the author himself was most likely to write based on his established vocabulary and grammar. For an author who writes Ἰησοῦς Χριστός six out of six times when naming Jesus and κύριος when describing Old Testament judgment suddenly to drop Χριστός in verse 5 and call the actor of the Exodus by the bare name Ἰησοῦς (a usage that never occurs anywhere else in his letter or anywhere else in the New Testament) is completely contrary to Jude’s own idiom.
2. Paleographical Assimilation of Nomina Sacra (ΚΣ → ΙΣ) Triggered by the End of Verse 4
Why, then, did Ἰησοῦς (ΙΣ) arise in an early Alexandrian ancestor of A, B, and 1739? The answer lies in the physical layout of Greek manuscripts and the psychology of scribal copying. In ancient Greek manuscripts, divine names were not written out in full (plene); they were contracted into two-letter nomina sacra with a supralinear stroke above them:
ΚΣ=κύριος(“Lord”)ΙΣ=Ἰησοῦς(“Jesus” / “Joshua”)ΘΣ=θεός(“God”)ΧΣ=Χριστός(“Christ”)
Look at the exact sequence of words across the boundary between the end of Jude 4 and the subject of Jude 5:
End of Jude 4:
...τὸν μόνον δεσπότην καὶ κύριον ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦν Χριστὸν ἀρνούμενοι.
(In manuscript nomina sacra:...ΚΝ ΗΜΩΝ ΙΝ ΧΝ ΑΡΝΟΥΜΕΝΟΙ)
Jude 5:Ὑπομνῆσαι δὲ ὑμᾶς βούλομαι, εἰδότας ὑμᾶς πάντα, ὅτι [ὁ] κύριος ἅπαξ λαὸν ἐκ γῆς Αἰγύπτου σώσας...
(In manuscript nomina sacra:...ΟΤΙ Ο ΚΣ ΑΠΑΞ ΛΑΟΝ...)
Only one short clause separates the emphatic closing words of verse 4 (κύριον ἡμῶν Ἰησοῦν Χριστόν, written ΚΝ ΗΜΩΝ ΙΝ ΧΝ) from the subject of verse 5 (Ο ΚΣ). In ancient copying, scribes held a short phrase of text in auditory and visual working memory while transferring their eyes from exemplar to page. Having just copied Ἰησοῦν Χριστόν (ΙΝ ΧΝ) as the climax of verse 4, a scribe encountering the single-letter difference between Ο ΚΣ and Ο ΙΣ (especially in a sentence about leading Israel out of Egypt into the wilderness, where Joshua, Ο ΙΣ, was the famous biblical leader alongside Moses) easily wrote Ο ΙΣ (ὁ Ἰησοῦς) by perseveration (backward assimilation to v. 4) or typological association with Joshua.
3. The Methodological Blind Spot of the CBGM at Locus-Specific Paleographical Corruptions
This exposes the central methodological weakness of the Coherence-Based Genealogical Method (CBGM) as applied in NA28 and UBS5. The CBGM is a powerful statistical tool for mapping overall textual flow across hundreds of variation units, but it operates with a well-known algorithmic bias: when two or three high-ranking Alexandrian witnesses (B, A, 1739) share an error that entered their common regional hyparchetype early, the CBGM’s global coherence metrics automatically assign massive weight to their agreement and treat that reading as the Ausgangstext (initial text), even when:
- An even earlier Alexandrian witness (Clement of Alexandria, c. 200 AD) proves that Alexandria at the end of the second century read
ὁ θεός(Ο ΘΣ) or “the Lord God,” notἸησοῦς(Ο ΙΣ); - Another fourth-century Alexandrian uncial (Codex Sinaiticus, ℵ) and fifth-century Codex Ephraemi (
C*) independently preserveὁ κύριος(Ο ΚΣ), agreeing with the entire Byzantine and Syriac Harklean traditions; - The reading
Ἰησοῦςviolates the author’s 100% invariant compound naming habit (Ἰησοῦς Χριστός); and - A transparent one-letter nomen sacrum slip (
ΚΣ→ΙΣ) immediately followingἸησοῦν Χριστόνin v. 4 accounts for the origin ofΙΣwithout attributing a stylistic and historical anomaly to the author himself.
As the UBS1–UBS4 / NA26–NA27 committee majority rightly recognized (over the dissent of Metzger and Wikgren), the rule lectio difficilior potior (“the more difficult reading is stronger”) does not mean that scribal blunders, nonsense readings, or paleographical assimilations should be promoted into the critical text simply because they are jarring. When a reading is both transcriptionally explicable as a nomen sacrum slip (ΚΣ → ΙΣ) and intrinsically alien to the author’s unbroken style, printing [ὁ] κύριος (“the Lord”), as the AI Critical New Testament (AICNT) does while supplying a full apparatus note on the Ἰησοῦς (“Jesus” / “Joshua”) and ὁ θεός (“God”) variants, remains the soundest judgment of reasoned eclecticism.
Conclusion: Why Jude Belongs Outside the Foundational Canon
When all the evidence (internal, literary, canonical, patristic, codicological, and textual-critical) is weighed together without dogmatic presuppositions, the case for dispensing with the Epistle of Jude as canonical Scripture is cumulative and compelling:
- Non-apostolic origin: The author makes no claim to be an apostle, identifies himself only as the brother of James (v. 1), and looks back on the preaching of “the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ” as a past generation distinct from himself (vv. 17–18).
- Certification of pseudepigrapha as history and prophecy: Jude explicitly validates 1 Enoch 1:9, a Hellenistic pseudepigraphon composed in the third or second century BCE, as genuine prophecy uttered by the historical “Enoch, the seventh from Adam” (vv. 14–15), while treating the Enochic Watchers mythology (v. 6) and the apocryphal Assumption of Moses (v. 9) as literal historical events on par with the Exodus.
- Canonical inconsistency with First Clement: If First Clement (c. 96 AD), despite its vastly superior second-century attestation, known Roman provenance, widespread public reading in the churches, and inclusion in Codex Alexandrinus, is rightly excluded from the canon because chapters 25–26 treat the myth of the Arabian Phoenix as literal fact, then Jude cannot consistently be retained as canonical Scripture when it treats First Enoch and the Assumption of Moses as literal history and prophecy.
- Centuries of ancient and Reformation rejection: Jude is unattested throughout the first eighty years of the second century, hedged by Origen, classified among the disputed antilegomena by Eusebius, excluded from the North African Cheltenham List, the Antiochene school (Chrysostom and Theodore of Mopsuestia), and the Syriac Peshitta, and explicitly reported by Didymus the Blind and Jerome as “rejected by many” because of its apocryphal citations, a judgment echoed at the Reformation by Martin Luther, Erasmus, Oecolampadius, and Cardinal Cajetan.
- Textual transmission in an apocryphal miscellany and severe variant instability: Its earliest Greek manuscript (
P72) is an early fourth-century miscellany binding Jude with the Nativity of Mary, 3 Corinthians, and the Odes of Solomon, copied by an erratic scribe whose work in Jude the Alands classified as a “free” text and whose theological and mechanical corruptions culminate in the four-way variant fracture at Jude 1:5.
Declining to treat the Epistle of Jude as canonical Scripture does not mean discarding it from the study of early Christian history. Like First Clement, the Didache, and the Epistle of Barnabas, Jude remains a valuable historical artifact illustrating how certain Jewish-Christian circles in the late first or early second century adapted Second Temple apocalyptic traditions to combat antinomian teachers. But historical interest is not canonical authority. Under the Apostolic Proximity Principle, the foundation of Christian faith and doctrine rests securely on the primary apostolic witnesses, above all Luke-Acts and the Pauline corpus, rather than on a twenty-five-verse disputed tract whose apocryphal sources and fractured text moved the ancient church itself to place it outside the core canon.
Footnotes
- See Josiah E. Verkaik, “Classifying the New Testament Authorities,” in The Case for the Core New Testament, NTcanon.com. ↩
- On the self-designation of Jude 1:1 and the distinction between Judas the brother of James/Jesus and the apostle Judas of James, see James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1911), 355–57 (ntarchive.org); Orello Cone and P. W. Schmiedel, “Jude, Epistle of,” in Encyclopaedia Biblica, vol. 2, ed. T. K. Cheyne and J. Sutherland Black (London: Adam and Charles Black, 1901), cols. 2630–32 (ntarchive.org); Richard J. Bauckham, Jude, 2 Peter, Word Biblical Commentary 50 (Waco, TX: Word Books, 1983), 14–16, 21–25; J. N. D. Kelly, A Commentary on the Epistles of Peter and of Jude, Thornapple Commentaries (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1969), 223–26. ↩
- James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament (1911), 346 (ntarchive.org:
#ch15-p53and#ch15-p54); Richard J. Bauckham, Jude, 2 Peter, WBC 50 (Waco, TX: Word Books, 1983), 16–17, 101–3; Bart D. Ehrman, Forgery and Counterforgery: The Use of Literary Deceit in Early Christian Polemics (New York: Oxford University Press, 2013), 299–303; Raymond E. Brown, An Introduction to the New Testament (New York: Doubleday, 1997), 749–59; Desiderius Erasmus, Annotationes in Novum Testamentum (Basel: Johann Froben, 1516), on Jude 17 (see n. 33 below); Martin Luther, Preface to the Epistles of St. James and St. Jude (1522), in Luther’s Works, vol. 35, Word and Sacrament I, ed. E. Theodore Bachmann (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg Press, 1960), 397–98. ↩ - For the detailed literary comparison demonstrating the priority of Jude and the redactional use of Jude 4–18 by 2 Peter 2:1–3:3, see James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament (1911), 348–52 (ntarchive.org:
#ch15-p58to#ch15-p62); Bauckham, Jude, 2 Peter, 141–43; Duane F. Watson, Invention, Arrangement, and Style: Rhetorical Criticism of Jude and 2 Peter, SBL Dissertation Series 104 (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1988), 163–87; Kelly, Epistles of Peter and of Jude, 226–31. ↩ - R. H. Charles, The Book of Enoch, or 1 Enoch: Translated from the Editor’s Ethiopic Text and Edited with the Introduction, Notes and Indexes of the First Edition Wholly Recast, Enlarged and Rewritten, Together with a Reprint from the Editor’s Text of the Greek Fragments (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1912), 7–8. ↩
- George W. E. Nickelsburg, 1 Enoch 1: A Commentary on the Book of 1 Enoch, Chapters 1–36; 81–108, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2001), 7, 142–43, 460–61; John J. Collins, The Apocalyptic Imagination: An Introduction to Jewish Apocalyptic Literature, 3rd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2016), 53–97. ↩
- Józef T. Milik, with the collaboration of Matthew Black, The Books of Enoch: Aramaic Fragments of Qumrân Cave 4 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1976), 140–49 (on
4Q201/4QEna arI iv 6–9 preserving the Aramaic text of 1 Enoch 1:9). ↩ - Charles, The Book of Enoch, 22–24 (1 Enoch 10:4–6, 12). ↩
- On the surviving sixth-century Latin palimpsest of the Assumption (Testament) of Moses discovered by Antonio Ceriani in the Ambrosian Library at Milan in 1861 and the patristic testimonies to its lost concluding section containing the dispute between Michael and the devil over Moses’ corpse, see R. H. Charles, The Assumption of Moses: Translated from the Latin Sixth Century MS., the Unemended Text of Which Is Published Herewith, Together with the Text in Its Restored and Critically Emended Form (London: Adam & Charles Black, 1897), 105–10; Johannes Tromp, The Assumption of Moses: A Critical Edition with Commentary, Studia in Veteris Testamenti Pseudepigrapha 10 (Leiden: Brill, 1993), 270–85; Bauckham, Jude, 2 Peter, 65–76. ↩
- Clement of Alexandria, Fragments of Clemens Alexandrinus: II. Comments on the Epistle of Jude (Adumbrationes in Epistolas Canonicas), in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 2, ed. Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson (New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1886), 573 (ntarchive.org:
#ch18-p28). ↩ - Origen, De Principiis (On First Principles) 3.2.1, trans. Frederick Crombie, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4, ed. Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson (New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1886), 328 (ntarchive.org:
#ch18-p110). ↩ - Didymus the Blind, In Epistolam Judae Enarratio, in J.-P. Migne, Patrologia Graeca, vol. 39 (Paris, 1863), col. 1815; discussed in Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament (London: Macmillan, 1889), 360 (ntarchive.org:
#ch7-p11), and Bruce M. Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament: Its Origin, Development, and Significance (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1987), 213–14. ↩ - Tertullian, On the Apparel of Women (De Cultu Feminarum) 1.3, trans. S. Thelwall, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4, 15–16 (ntarchive.org:
#ch2-p4to#ch2-p6). ↩ - Augustine of Hippo, The City of God (De Civitate Dei) 15.23, trans. Marcus Dods, in A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church, 1st ser., vol. 2, ed. Philip Schaff (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887), 304–5 (ntarchive.org:
#ch18-p55). ↩ - Augustine of Hippo, The City of God 18.38, in NPNF 1st ser., vol. 2, 383 (ntarchive.org:
#ch21-p61). ↩ - For the early patristic testimonies to 1 Clement, see J. B. Lightfoot, The Apostolic Fathers, Part 1, S. Clement of Rome: A Revised Text with Introductions, Notes, Dissertations, and Translations, vol. 1 (London: Macmillan, 1890), 148–200 (ntarchive.org:
#ch5-p2to#ch5-p105); Eusebius, Church History 3.16 (ntarchive.org), 4.22.1, 4.23.11; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.3 (ntarchive.org); Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 4.17 (ntarchive.org). ↩ - Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament (London: Macmillan, 1889), 48 (ntarchive.org:
#ch2-p66); compare the tabular finding of the Oxford Society of Historical Theology in The New Testament in the Apostolic Fathers (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1905), 137 (ntarchive.org:#ch3-p367), where Jude fails to register even a single classA,B,C, orDliterary parallel across the Apostolic Fathers. ↩ - Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History 3.16, trans. Arthur Cushman McGiffert, in A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd ser., vol. 1, ed. Philip Schaff and Henry Wace (New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1890), 147–48 (ntarchive.org:
#ch5-p109). ↩ - On the inclusion of 1–2 Clement inside the New Testament of fifth-century Codex Alexandrinus (
A/02) and sixth-century Syriac New TestamentAdd. 14470, see J. B. Lightfoot, S. Clement of Rome, vol. 1 (1890), 116–47 (ntarchive.org:#ch4-p2to#ch4-p45); Dan Batovici, “The Apostolic Fathers in Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Alexandrinus,” Biblica 97, no. 4 (2016): 581–605; Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 214, 223. ↩ - Clement of Rome, 1 Clement 25:1–26:1, in J. B. Lightfoot, The Apostolic Fathers, Part 1, S. Clement of Rome, vol. 2 (London: Macmillan, 1890), 285 (ntarchive.org:
#ch7-p26and#ch7-p27); see also Lightfoot’s extensive commentary notes on the Phoenix myth at pp. 84–88 (ntarchive.org:#ch2-p594to#ch2-p596) and the alternative translation in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1 (1885), 11–12 (ntarchive.org:#ch2-p35and#ch2-p36). ↩ - Photius of Constantinople, Bibliotheca, Codex 126 (author’s translation from the Greek text quoted and discussed in J. B. Lightfoot, S. Clement of Rome, vol. 1, p. 196 [ntarchive.org:
#ch5-p100], and vol. 2, pp. 62, 84 [ntarchive.org:#ch2-p444and#ch2-p594]; compare the English translation in J. H. Freese, The Library of Photius, vol. 1 [London: SPCK, 1920], 208–9). ↩ - Origen, Commentary on Matthew 17.30 (Εἰ δὲ καὶ τὴν Ἰούδα προσίετό τις ἐπιστολήν), ed. Erich Klostermann, Origenes Werke, vol. 10, GCS 40 (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs, 1935), 671 (author’s translation; compare Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, 369 [ntarchive.org:
#ch7-p29]). ↩ - Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History 2.23.25, trans. Arthur Cushman McGiffert, in NPNF 2nd ser., vol. 1, 128 (ntarchive.org:
#ch4-p105). ↩ - Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History 3.25.3, in NPNF 2nd ser., vol. 1, 156 (ntarchive.org:
#ch5-p166). ↩ - Didymus the Blind, In Epistolam Judae Enarratio (PG 39:1815, author’s translation from the Latin text; compare the translation and discussion in Tommy Wasserman, The Epistle of Jude: Its Text and Transmission, Coniectanea Biblica New Testament Series 43 [Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International, 2006], 73–74, and Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, 360 [ntarchive.org:
#ch7-p11]). ↩ - Jerome, Lives of Illustrious Men (De Viris Illustribus) 4, trans. Ernest Cushing Richardson, in A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd ser., vol. 3, ed. Philip Schaff and Henry Wace (New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1892), 362 (ntarchive.org:
#ch14-p10). ↩ - On the Cheltenham List (Mommsen Catalogue, c. 360 AD) omitting James, Jude, and Hebrews, see Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, xxxviii–xxxix, 566–68 (ntarchive.org:
#note-to-the-seventh-edition-p11and#app7-p2); Theodor Mommsen, “Zur lateinischen Stichometrie,” Hermes 21 (1886): 142–56; Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 231–32, 310–11. ↩ - On the exclusion of Jude by the School of Antioch (Chrysostom, Theodore of Mopsuestia, and Severus), see Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, 441–44 (ntarchive.org:
#ch10-p9to#ch10-p14); Moffatt, Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, 352–53 (ntarchive.org:#ch15-p64); Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 214–16. ↩ - Amphilochius of Iconium, Iambi ad Seleucum, lines 310–15; translated in Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, 440, 557 (ntarchive.org:
#ch10-p7and#app4-p26), and Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 313–14. ↩ - On the Syriac Peshitta omitting Jude, 2 Peter, 2–3 John, and Revelation, see Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, 247–50 (ntarchive.org:
#ch4-p28to#ch4-p32); Philip Schaff, Companion to the Greek Testament and the English Version, in The New Testament in the Original Greek, ed. B. F. Westcott and F. J. A. Hort (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1882), xxxviii (ntarchive.org:#ch2-p50); Sebastian P. Brock, The Bible in the Syriac Tradition, 2nd ed. (Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias Press, 2006), 17–18, 34–35. ↩ - Junilius Africanus, Instituta Regularia Divinae Legis 1.6–7, discussed in Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, 444–46 (ntarchive.org:
#ch10-p15to#ch10-p16), and Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 216, 237–38. ↩ - Martin Luther, Preface to the Epistles of St. James and St. Jude (1522), in Luther’s Works, vol. 35, Word and Sacrament I, ed. E. Theodore Bachmann (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg Press, 1960), 397–98; compare the translations and analyses in Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, 490–91 (ntarchive.org:
#ch11-p30to#ch11-p35), and Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 6 (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1882), 35–36 (ntarchive.org:#ch4-p121to#ch4-p125). ↩ - Desiderius Erasmus, Novum Instrumentum omne... cum Annotationibus (Basel: Johann Froben, 1516), annotations on the Epistle of Jude; see Westcott, General Survey of the Canon, 479–81 (ntarchive.org:
#ch11-p13), and Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament, 241–42. ↩ - On Cardinal Cajetan (Thomas de Vio) and Johannes Oecolampadius on Jude and the disputed books, see Brooke Foss Westcott, A General Survey of the History of the Canon of the New Testament, 483–84, 495–96 (ntarchive.org:
#ch11-p18and#ch11-p41). ↩ - Michel Testuz, Papyrus Bodmer VII–IX: VII: L’Épître de Jude; VIII: Les deux Épîtres de Pierre; IX: Les Psaumes 33 et 34 (Cologny-Geneva: Bibliothèque Bodmer, 1959); Eric G. Turner, The Typology of the Early Codex (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1977), 79–80; Pasquale Orsini and Willy Clarysse, “Early New Testament Manuscripts and Their Dates: A Critique of Theological Palaeography,” Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses 88 (2012): 443–74, at 471 (assigning P72 to 250–350 AD); Brent Nongbri, God’s Library: The Archaeology of the Earliest Christian Manuscripts (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2018), 196–215. ↩
- On the structure, scribes, and compilation of the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex containing P72, see Tommy Wasserman, “Papyrus 72 and the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex,” New Testament Studies 51, no. 1 (2005): 137–54; Wasserman, The Epistle of Jude: Its Text and Transmission, 30–50; Nongbri, God’s Library, 196–215; Kim Haines-Eitzen, Guardians of Letters: Literacy, Power, and the Transmitters of Early Christian Literature (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), 96–104. ↩
- Wasserman, The Epistle of Jude: Its Text and Transmission, 30–50. ↩
- Wasserman, “Papyrus 72 and the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex,” New Testament Studies 51, no. 1 (2005): 140–48 (esp. pp. 144, 148 on Scribe B copying 3 Corinthians, the Eleventh Ode of Solomon, Jude, and 1–2 Peter, while Scribe A copied The Nativity of Mary). ↩
- James R. Royse, Scribal Habits in Early Greek New Testament Papyri, New Testament Tools, Studies and Documents 36 (Leiden: Brill, 2008), ch. 8, pp. 545–614 (esp. pp. 552, 559–65 on corrections, orthographic singulars, and nonsense readings, and pp. 608–14 on Coptic phonetic interference and scribal profile). ↩
- Carlo Maria Martini, Beati Petri Apostoli Epistulae ex Papyro Bodmeriana VIII transcriptae, Papyrologica Castroctaviana 2 (Milan: Centro di Studi Papirologici / Vita e Pensiero, 1968), xvii (trans. James R. Royse, Scribal Habits in Early Greek New Testament Papyri [Leiden: Brill, 2008], 552 n. 38; cf. Wasserman, The Epistle of Jude, 42). ↩
- Sakae Kubo, P72 and the Codex Vaticanus, Studies and Documents 27 (Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1965), 25–33. ↩
- Kurt Aland and Barbara Aland, The Text of the New Testament: An Introduction to the Critical Editions and to the Theory and Practice of Modern Textual Criticism, trans. Erroll F. Rhodes, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989), 100. ↩
- Bart D. Ehrman, The Orthodox Corruption of Scripture: The Effect of Early Christological Controversies on the Text of the New Testament (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993), 85–86 (on 2 Pet 1:2 and Jude 5) and 266 (on 1 Pet 5:1; 2nd ed. 2011, pp. 97–99, 309); synthesized as a combined theological profile of the scribe of P72 in Tommy Wasserman, “Papyrus 72 and the Bodmer Miscellaneous Codex,” NTS 51 (2005): 152–54, and The Epistle of Jude, 45–47. ↩
- Clement of Alexandria, The Instructor (Paedagogus) 3.8, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 2, 282 (ntarchive.org:
#ch9-p76; Greek text ed. Otto Stählin, GCS 12:262: εἰδέναι γὰρ ὑμᾶς βούλομαι, φησὶν ὁ Ἰούδας, ὅτι ὁ θεὸς ἅπαξ λαὸν ἐκ γῆς Αἰγύπτου σώσας τὸ δεύτερον τοὺς μὴ πιστεύσαντας ἀπώλεσεν); and Clement of Alexandria, Fragments: II. Comments on the Epistle of Jude, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 2, 573 (ntarchive.org:#ch18-p27). ↩ - Jerome, Letter XLVI (Paula and Eustochium to Marcella, 386 AD), § 7, trans. W. H. Fremantle, in A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd ser., vol. 6, ed. Philip Schaff and Henry Wace (New York: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1893), 63 (ntarchive.org:
#ch5-p12); and Jerome, Against Jovinianus (Adversus Jovinianum, 393 AD) 1.21, trans. W. H. Fremantle, in NPNF 2nd ser., vol. 6, 361–62 (ntarchive.org:#ch14-p44). ↩ - Allen Wikgren, “Some Problems in Jude 5,” in Studies in the History and Text of the New Testament in Honor of Kenneth Willis Clark, ed. Boyd L. Daniels and M. Jack Suggs, Studies and Documents 29 (Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1967), 147–52. ↩
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed. (Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft / United Bible Societies, 1994), 657–58 (majority note on p. 657; signed minority dissent by Bruce M. Metzger and Allen Wikgren on p. 658). ↩
- Brooke Foss Westcott and Fenton John Anthony Hort, The New Testament in the Original Greek, vol. 2, Introduction, Appendix (Cambridge and London: Macmillan, 1881), Appendix, “Notes on Select Readings,” 106–7; compare Orello Cone and P. W. Schmiedel, “Jude, Epistle of,” in Encyclopaedia Biblica, vol. 2 (1901), col. 2630 (ntarchive.org:
#ch9-p2166). ↩ - Barbara Aland, Kurt Aland, Gerd Mink, Holger Strutwolf, and Klaus Wachtel, eds., Novum Testamentum Graecum: Editio Critica Maior, vol. IV: Catholic Letters, Part 1: Text, 2nd rev. ed. (Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft, 2013), 390–91; Gerd Mink, “Problems of a Highly Contaminated Tradition: The New Testament: Stemmata of Variants as a Source of a Genealogy for Witnesses,” in Studies in Stemmatology II, ed. Pieter van Reenen, August den Hollander, and Margot van Mulken (Amsterdam: John Benjamins, 2004), 13–85; Tommy Wasserman, “Criteria for Evaluating Readings in New Testament Textual Criticism,” in The Text of the New Testament in Contemporary Research: Essays on the Status Quaestionis, ed. Bart D. Ehrman and Michael W. Holmes, 2nd ed. (Leiden: Brill, 2013), 579–612. ↩