NTcanon.comCore NT Series
Case for the Core New Testament
Lukan Priority
Issues with Mark
Issues with Matthew
Issues with John
Luke Primacy
Other Issues

Issues with Matthew

Survey of Matthean Posteriority Scholarship

Historical Survey of Scholarship Attesting to Matthew’s Dependence on Luke

Although modern introductions to the Synoptic Problem have often focused on the Two-Document Hypothesis (Mark + Q) and the Farrer Hypothesis (Mark → Matthew → Luke), a substantial lineage of critical scholars extending from the late eighteenth century to the present has argued for Matthean Posteriority—the conclusion that canonical Matthew was the last of the three Synoptic Gospels to be composed and drew directly upon Luke as well as Mark. As surveyed and expanded in Robert K. MacEwen’s monograph Matthean Posteriority: An Exploration of Matthew’s Use of Mark and Luke as a Solution to the Synoptic Problem, Library of New Testament Studies 501 (London: Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2015), ch. 1, pp. 5–26 (Internet Archive), major representatives of this tradition include Gottlob Christian Storr, Johann Gottfried Herder, Christian Gottlob Wilke, Gustav Schläger, William Lockton, Ernst von Dobschütz, H. Philip West Jr., Ronald V. Huggins, Evan Powell, Martin Hengel, George A. Blair, Alan J. P. Garrow, James R. Edwards, and MacEwen himself.

Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Pioneers

Gottlob Christian Storr (1786)

Gottlob Christian Storr (1746–1805), professor of theology at Tübingen, appears to have been the earliest modern scholar to propose that Matthew wrote in literary dependence upon both Mark and Luke, in his treatise Über den Zweck der evangelischen Geschichte und der Briefe Johannis (Tübingen: Jakob Friedrich Heerbrandt, 1786), pp. 274–302 (surveyed in MacEwen 2015, p. 7). Comparing the narrative sequences of the three Gospels, Storr observed that whereas Mark and Luke preserve a broadly chronological framework, Matthew groups traditions into artificial topical blocks—indicating that canonical Matthew represents a secondary, thematic rearrangement of earlier Gospel accounts.

Johann Gottfried Herder (1796–1797)

In two influential studies on Gospel origins—Vom Erlöser der Menschen: Nach unsern drei ersten Evangelien (Riga: Johann Friedrich Hartknoch, 1796) and Von Gottes Sohn, der Welt Heiland (Riga: Hartknoch, 1797)—the German philosopher and theologian Johann Gottfried Herder (1744–1803) emphasized oral gospel preaching while arguing that canonical Greek Matthew was composed last among the three Synoptic Gospels, exhibiting a more developed ecclesiastical, apologetic, and scriptural-proof structure than either Mark or Luke (see MacEwen 2015, pp. 7–8).

Christian Gottlob Wilke (1838)

In his exhaustive 700-page philological study Der Urevangelist, oder exegetisch kritische Untersuchung über das Verwandtschaftsverhältniß der drei ersten Evangelien (Dresden and Leipzig: Gerhard Fleischer, 1838), esp. pp. 684–691 (surveyed in MacEwen 2015, p. 8), Christian Gottlob Wilke (1786–1854) defended a direct-utilization model in which Matthew wrote third, using Mark as his narrative template and supplementing Mark directly from Luke. Wilke organized his evidence for Matthew’s dependence on Luke around four key observations:

  1. Editorial seams within Matthew betray how the evangelist extracted double-tradition sayings (material shared by Matthew and Luke) from their prior Lukan settings and stitched them into composite discourses such as the Sermon on the Mount.
  2. Matthew repeatedly modifies double-tradition wording as a consequence of relocating Lukan sayings into new topical contexts.
  3. Distinctively Lukan vocabulary surfaces inside Matthean parallel passages.
  4. Double-tradition units embedded in Matthew still retain traces of Luke’s own redactional concerns, proving that Luke was the donor text rather than the recipient.

Gustav Schläger (1896)

Near the close of the nineteenth century, Gustav Schläger published a focused lexical investigation, “Die Abhängigkeit des Matthäusevangeliums vom Lukasevangelium,” Theologische Studien und Kritiken 69 (1896): 83–93 (surveyed in MacEwen 2015, pp. 8–9). Cataloging words, idioms, and syntactic constructions characteristic of Luke-Acts as a whole that recur both in double-tradition parallels and in the minor agreements of Matthew and Luke against Mark, Schläger argued that such Lukanisms inside Matthew cannot be explained by an independent Q source and point directly to Matthew’s literary use of Luke.

Early and Mid-Twentieth-Century Developments

William Lockton (1922–1926)

In a trio of works published in the 1920s—“The Origin of the Gospels,” Church Quarterly Review 94 (July 1922): 216–239 (Internet Archive); The Resurrection and Other Gospel Narratives (London: Longmans, Green, 1924; Internet Archive); and The Three Traditions in the Gospels: An Essay in Synoptic Criticism (London: Longmans, Green, 1926; Internet Archive)—the Anglican scholar William Lockton directly anticipated Robert L. Lindsey and the Jerusalem School by arguing for the sequential order Luke → Mark → Matthew:

  1. Progressive development from Luke to Mark to Matthew: Across parallel narratives, theological and literary development moves consistently from Luke through Mark to Matthew (The Three Traditions in the Gospels, pp. 3–4, 32–37; “The Origin of the Gospels,” p. 222).
  2. Artificial literary architecture: Matthew exhibits the most schematic and secondary structural design of all three Synoptic Gospels (The Three Traditions in the Gospels, pp. 3–4, 32–37).
  3. Infancy-narrative contact: Beneath their surface divergences, Matthew 1–2 and Luke 1–2 share enough structural motifs that they can scarcely be wholly independent, with Matthew reacting to earlier Lukan tradition (The Resurrection and Other Gospel Narratives, pp. 131–133).
  4. Lukan diction in the double tradition: Double-tradition vocabulary aligns far more closely with Luke’s overall style than with Matthew’s (“The Origin of the Gospels,” p. 222).

Ernst von Dobschütz (1928)

Ernst von Dobschütz (1870–1934), Professor of New Testament at Halle, argued in his influential essay “Matthäus als Rabbi und Katechet,” Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft 27 (1928): 338–348—translated as “Matthew as Rabbi and Catechist,” in The Interpretation of Matthew, ed. Graham N. Stanton, 2nd ed., Studies in New Testament Interpretation (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1995), pp. 27–38 (Internet Archive)—that Matthew depended upon Luke “at least in a secondary way” (ET pp. 34–36). Pointing to the minor agreements against Mark, the construction and expansion of Matthew’s major discourses out of double-tradition sayings, and Matthew’s rabbinic-catechetical habits of stereotyped repetition, Dobschütz classified canonical Matthew alongside James, the Pastoral Epistles, and the Shepherd of Hermas as an early “catholicizing” church manual composed around 100 CE, chronologically posterior to both Mark and Luke (ET p. 37).

H. Philip West Jr. (1967)

In “A Primitive Version of Luke in the Composition of Matthew,” New Testament Studies 14, no. 1 (1967): 75–95 (Cambridge Core), H. Philip West Jr. built upon John Knox’s proposal (Marcion and the New Testament: An Essay in the Early History of the Canon [Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1942]) that canonical Luke expanded an earlier “Primitive Luke” shorter in scope. West demonstrated in detail (pp. 80–88) that Matthew’s omission of large stretches of Lukan special material—particularly passages foregrounding women, sympathetic Samaritans/Gentiles, and radical renunciation of wealth—is fully explained by Matthew’s own conservative Jewish-Christian redactional priorities, and that Matthew constructed his great discourses out of Lukan material using the very same editorial techniques he applied to Mark, eliminating any need for Q.

The Modern Revival of Matthean Posteriority (1992–Present)

Ronald V. Huggins (1992)

Ronald V. Huggins reintroduced direct Matthean dependence on Mark and Luke into contemporary Synoptic debate—and coined the modern designation “Matthean Posteriority”—in “Matthean Posteriority: A Preliminary Proposal,” Novum Testamentum 34, no. 1 (1992): 1–22 (reprinted in The Synoptic Problem and Q: Selected Studies from Novum Testamentum, ed. David E. Orton [Leiden: Brill, 1999], pp. 204–225). Dispensing with hypothetical intermediary documents, Huggins showed that the classic Two-Document objection regarding the divergent placement of double-tradition sayings in Matthew and Luke poses no difficulty once Mark is recognized as Matthew’s primary narrative spine and Luke as his supplementary quarry of teaching blocks (1992, pp. 9–11; 1999 repr., pp. 212–214).

Evan Powell (1994, 2006)

Across two books—The Unfinished Gospel: Notes on the Quest for the Historical Jesus (Westlake Village, CA: Symposium Books, 1994; Internet Archive) and The Myth of the Lost Gospel (Las Vegas: Symposium Press, 2006)—Evan Powell mounted a comprehensive critique of Q in favor of Matthean posteriority. Powell emphasized an important consistency argument (2006, pp. 50, 107–120): under the Two-Document Hypothesis, Luke must be imagined taking sweeping liberties with Mark’s wording and order while suddenly copying Q with near-verbatim conservatism; under Matthean posteriority, by contrast, Matthew displays one and the same conservative copying of sayings combined with bold topical rearrangement across both Mark and Luke.

Martin Hengel (2000)

In The Four Gospels and the One Gospel of Jesus Christ: An Investigation of the Collection and Origin of the Canonical Gospels, trans. John Bowden (Harrisburg, PA: Trinity Press International, 2000), pp. 169–207 (cf. MacEwen 2015, pp. 16–19), the eminent Tübingen historian Martin Hengel (1926–2009) broke with the German Two-Source consensus to argue that canonical Matthew wrote after Luke (c. 90–100 CE vs. Luke c. 75–80 CE) and made direct secondary use of Luke alongside Mark and oral/written sayings traditions. Hengel grounded this chronological order in Matthew’s post-Jamnian confrontation with rabbinic Pharisaism, liturgical formalization of the Lord’s Prayer and baptismal commission, and later apostolic title (“According to Matthew”).

George A. Blair (2003)

In The Synoptic Gospels Compared, Studies in the Bible and Early Christianity 55 (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 2003; surveyed in MacEwen 2015, pp. 19–20), George A. Blair conducted a pericope-by-pericope comparison across the entire Synoptic tradition, arguing throughout that Matthew functioned as a harmonizing and clarifying editor who worked directly from Mark and Luke.

Alan J. P. Garrow (2004, 2016)

British New Testament scholar Alan J. P. Garrow first explored Matthean redactional dependence on early Syrian church tradition in The Gospel of Matthew’s Dependence on the Didache, Journal for the Study of the New Testament Supplement Series 254 (London: T&T Clark, 2004; reviewed by John S. Kloppenborg in Biblica 86, no. 3 [2005]: 416–419, JSTOR), and subsequently developed a modified Matthean Posteriority model—which he terms the Matthew Conflator Hypothesis (MCH)—in “Streeter’s ‘Other’ Synoptic Solution: The Matthew Conflator Hypothesis,” New Testament Studies 62, no. 2 (2016): 207–226 (building on earlier conference papers surveyed in MacEwen 2015, pp. 20–22). Garrow highlights two critical data points: (1) high-agreement double-tradition passages reflect Matthew’s direct visual copying of Luke, while alternating low-agreement passages involve episodic sayings materials shared by Luke and Matthew; and (2) Matthew’s intricate conflation of Mark and Luke reflects early Christian adoption of the leaf-codex format, allowing the evangelist to flip forward and backward in Luke while following Mark sequentially.

James R. Edwards (2009)

In The Hebrew Gospel and the Development of the Synoptic Tradition (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2009), pp. 243–262, James R. Edwards distinguishes sharply between patristic testimony to an early Semitic Gospel associated with the apostle Matthew (which Edwards argues served as a source for Special Luke) and canonical Greek Matthew. Analyzing canonical Matthew’s elaborate five-book architecture, Septuagintal alignment, heightened Christological titles, synagogue polemic, and parallel pericopes with Mark and Luke, Edwards concludes that canonical Matthew was the last of the three Synoptic Gospels to be written and was not authored by the apostle Matthew.

Robert K. MacEwen (2015)

In Matthean Posteriority: An Exploration of Matthew’s Use of Mark and Luke as a Solution to the Synoptic Problem, LNTS 501 (London: Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2015), Robert K. MacEwen provides the fullest recent monograph testing direct Matthean dependence on Mark and Luke without Q. Combining nine contextual case studies where Matthew betrays awareness of Luke’s surrounding chapters (ch. 2, pp. 27–57) with a statistical study of verbatim Greek agreement strings in triple- and double-tradition pericopes (ch. 3–5), MacEwen concludes that Matthew consistently stands in the mediating position between Mark and Luke:

“Huggins, at the end of the twentieth century, reintroduced Matthean posteriority as an option, providing the theory with a memorable name and giving a credible account of Matthew’s procedure in using Mark as his primary source and Luke as his secondary source. Powell argued that an MPH view of Matthew’s consistency in conservatively copying from both Mark and Luke is more reasonable than the 2DH view of Luke conservatively copying passages while taking great liberties with Mark. Hengel offered a generally plausible account of historical factors affecting the development of the Synoptic Gospels and took a mediating position between the MPH and the 2DH... Garrow succinctly and persuasively showed how the MPH can explain the key data of the Synoptic Gospels.” (MacEwen 2015, pp. 24–25)

Synthesizing two centuries of research alongside his own textual findings, MacEwen identifies seven converging lines of evidence for Matthew’s dependence on Luke (adapted from MacEwen 2015, p. 26):

  1. Asymmetric verbal agreement: Matthew shares high verbatim agreement with Mark and high verbatim agreement with Luke, whereas Mark and Luke exhibit much lower verbatim agreement with one another.
  2. Editorial plausibility of discourse construction: Matthew’s gathering of dispersed Lukan sayings into five thematic discourses matches how Matthew handles Mark, whereas Luke’s supposed dismantling of Matthew’s discourses defies editorial explanation.
  3. Consistent secondary development: Across liturgy, Christology, miracle-heightening, and apologetics, Matthew appears more developed than Mark and Luke.
  4. Redactional coherence of omissions: Matthew’s omission of Lukan Sondergut corresponds directly to Matthew’s own theological and stylistic preferences.
  5. Post-70 historical setting: Matthew’s confrontation with emergent rabbinic Pharisaism situates the First Gospel later in the first century than Luke-Acts.
  6. Infancy and resurrection touchpoints: Even in framing chapters (Matt 1–2; 28), Matthew shows apologetic responsiveness to traditions preserved more primitively in Luke.
  7. Reversible characteristic vocabulary: Distinctively Lukan linguistic markers carried over into Matthean parallels confirm directional borrowing from Luke to Matthew.