NTcanon.comCore NT Series
Case for the Core New Testament
Lukan Priority
Issues with Mark
Issues with Matthew
Issues with John
Luke Primacy
Other Issues

Issues with John

John vs the Synoptics

The "Johannine Problem": John Versus the Synoptic Gospels

No reader who turns directly from Matthew, Mark, and Luke to the Fourth Gospel can miss the startling shift in atmosphere, chronology, geography, literary idiom, and Christological self-presentation. Already in the early third century, Origen of Alexandria acknowledged in Book 10 of his Commentary on John that on the outward plane of historical chronology the Fourth Gospel and the three Synoptic Gospels cannot be harmonized without violence to the text. Since the rise of modern historical criticism in the nineteenth century—spearheaded by scholars such as Karl Gottlieb Bretschneider (Probabilia de evangelii et epistolarum Joannis, apostoli, indole et origine, 1820), David Friedrich Strauss (The Life of Jesus Critically Examined, 1835–1836), and Ferdinand Christian Baur (Kritische Untersuchungen über die kanonischen Evangelien, 1847)—critical scholarship across the theological spectrum has recognized that the Synoptic Gospels preserve the primary historical framework of Jesus' Galilean ministry and teaching, whereas the Fourth Gospel represents a profound theological and dramatic reinterpretation composed decades later.

Contemporary Historical-Critical Consensus: James D. G. Dunn (2003, 2015)

In the opening and closing volumes of his magisterial trilogy Christianity in the Making—Jesus Remembered, vol. 1 (Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2003), pp. 165–167, and Neither Jew nor Greek: A Contested Identity, vol. 3 (Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2015), pp. 613–616, 632–636, 642, 670–671—British New Testament historian James D. G. Dunn summarizes why virtually all critical historians treat the Synoptics rather than John as their foundational source for the life and teaching of Jesus. Dunn highlights three decisive considerations:

  1. Divergent Chronology, Geography, and Narrative Triggers: Whereas the Synoptics depict an essentially Galilean ministry culminating in a single fateful Passover journey to Jerusalem—where Jesus' cleansing of the temple triggers the high-priestly plot against him—John locates Jesus repeatedly in Jerusalem across at least three Passovers, moves the temple cleansing to the very start of his public career (John 2:13–22), and substitutes the raising of Lazarus (John 11:1–53)—an astounding public miracle unknown to Matthew, Mark, and Luke—as the proximate cause of Jesus' arrest (Dunn 2003, p. 165; 2015, p. 636).
  2. Uniform Johannine Discourse Idiom: Echoing David Friedrich Strauss's classic literary observation, Dunn notes that in place of the pithy aphorisms and vivid parables of the Synoptic Jesus, the Johannine Jesus delivers extended, spiral-like theological monologues in the exact same distinctive style as John the Baptist, the Gospel's narrator, and the author of 1 John—demonstrating that the prose voice belongs to the Evangelist rather than verbatim memory of Jesus (Dunn 2003, pp. 165–166; 2015, p. 615).
  3. Displacement of the Kingdom of God by Christological Self-Proclamation: In the Synoptics, Jesus' central proclamation is the Kingdom of God while explicit self-claims remain restrained; in John, the Kingdom recedes to two verses (John 3:3, 5) and is replaced by overt Christological self-disclosure, above all the seven predicated and several absolute "I am" (egō eimi) pronouncements. Had the historical Jesus publicly uttered such unforgettable self-assertions throughout Galilee and Judea, Dunn asks, it would be inexplicable that Mark, Q, Matthew, and Luke all omitted them completely (Dunn 2003, p. 166; 2015, pp. 615–616).

Accordingly, Dunn states the enduring historical-critical verdict in Jesus Remembered and refines its hermeneutical corollary in Neither Jew nor Greek:

On the whole, then, the position is unchanged: John's gospel cannot be regarded as a source for the life and the teaching of Jesus of the same order as the Synoptics... We shall certainly want to call upon John's gospel as a source, but mostly as a secondary source to supplement or corroborate the testimony of the Synoptic tradition. (James D. G. Dunn, Jesus Remembered, Christianity in the Making, vol. 1 [Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2003], pp. 166–167)

Were the question of historicity a real one for John and his audiences, in the same way as is the case today, he would probably have confirmed that he was not attempting to provide a historical record of what Jesus did and said. His concern was rather to bring out the truth of Jesus as they now perceived it, the fuller significance of the historical life and mission of Jesus which only became clear to them with the passing of some decades... To miss this probable conclusion and to insist that John has to be read on the same terms and level as the Synoptics is most likely to miss what John saw himself as doing. (James D. G. Dunn, Neither Jew nor Greek: A Contested Identity, Christianity in the Making, vol. 3 [Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2015], pp. 670–671)

Summary Comparison: The Synoptic Gospels Versus the Gospel of John

The table below synthesizes the principal historical, structural, and theological contrasts between the Synoptic tradition and the Fourth Gospel (adapted and expanded in analytical summary from James D. G. Dunn, Neither Jew nor Greek [Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2015], pp. 613–614, alongside standard Synoptic–Johannine comparisons):

Dimension of Comparison The Synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke) The Gospel of John
Opening of the Narrative Human genealogy and infancy narratives (Matt 1–2; Luke 1–2) or John the Baptist's desert preaching and baptism of Jesus (Mark 1:1–11). Cosmic Prologue of the eternal Logos ("Word") becoming flesh (John 1:1–18); no birth narrative and no explicit account of Jesus' baptism by John.
Wilderness Temptation Forty-day testing in the wilderness by Satan immediately following Jesus' baptism (Matt 4:1–11; Mark 1:12–13; Luke 4:1–13). Omitted entirely; within days of the Baptist's witness, Jesus calls disciples and attends the wedding at Cana (John 1:19–2:11).
Geographic Center & Duration Ministry centered predominantly in Galilee and surrounding regions, culminating in a single final Passover journey to Jerusalem (within roughly one year). Ministry centered repeatedly in Judea and Jerusalem around Jewish festivals, spanning at least three Passovers (John 2:13; 6:4; 11:55) over two to three years.
John the Baptist's Ministry Jesus begins his public Galilean ministry after John is arrested and imprisoned (Matt 4:12; Mark 1:14; cf. Luke 3:19–20). Jesus and John conduct overlapping baptizing ministries in Judea prior to John's imprisonment (John 3:22–24); John functions purely as a Christological witness.
Cleansing of the Temple & Plot to Kill Jesus Placed during Passion Week at the close of Jesus' ministry, serving as the decisive provocation that triggers the priestly plot to destroy him (Matt 21:12–13; Mark 11:15–18; Luke 19:45–48). Placed at the outset of Jesus' public ministry (John 2:13–22); the raising of Lazarus from four days in the tomb (John 11:45–53)—absent from all three Synoptics—triggers the Sanhedrin's decree.
Miracles & Exorcisms Frequent exorcisms of unclean spirits alongside healings wrought out of compassion in response to faith; refusal of "signs" demanded by skeptics (Mark 8:11–12). Zero exorcisms anywhere in the Gospel; seven selected, heightened "signs" (sēmeia—water to wine, thirty-eight-year paralytic, man born blind, Lazarus dead four days) staged to manifest Jesus' glory and induce belief (John 2:11; 20:30–31).
Teaching Form & Style Terse, memorable aphorisms, beatitudes, ethical precepts, and narrative parables tailored to peasant and village life in Galilee. Extended, abstract, dialectical discourses and symbolic allegories (Good Shepherd, True Vine) structured around recurring misunderstandings, spoken in uniform Johannine prose.
Central Message & Self-Claims Proclamation of the Reign/Kingdom of God, repentance, love of God and neighbor, and discipleship; restrained messianic self-disclosure prior to Caesarea Philippi and the Passion. The "Kingdom of God" appears only in John 3:3, 5, replaced by "eternal life" and explicit Christological self-revelation ("I am the bread of life," "the light of the world," "before Abraham was, I am") from chapter 1 onward.
Last Supper & Eucharistic Words Celebrated as a Passover meal on the evening of 15 Nisan, featuring the institution of the bread and cup (Matt 26:17–29; Mark 14:12–25; Luke 22:7–20). Held before the Feast of Passover (John 13:1); Eucharistic institution is omitted at the meal (replaced by footwashing in 13:4–17 and Farewell Discourses in chs. 14–17), while flesh-and-blood imagery appears earlier at Capernaum (John 6:51–58).
Garden Prayer & Crucifixion Date Agony of prayer in Gethsemane ("remove this cup from me," Luke 22:42 // Mark 14:36); crucified on Passover day (15 Nisan), uttering the cry of dereliction (Mark 15:34 // Matt 27:46) or commending his spirit (Luke 23:46). Gethsemane agony explicitly rejected ("Shall I say, 'Father, save me from this hour'?" John 12:27); arresting cohort falls to the ground at "I am he" (18:6); crucified on the Day of Preparation (14 Nisan, 19:14, 31) as Passover lambs are slaughtered, dying with sovereign finality: "It is finished" (19:30).

Early Twentieth-Century Critical Verdicts: V. H. Stanton (1920) and C. H. Dodd (1928)

Long before late twentieth-century quests for the historical Jesus, leading British New Testament scholars had reached the same comparative conclusion. In The Gospels as Historical Documents, Part III: The Fourth Gospel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1920), p. 209, Regius Professor of Divinity at Cambridge Vincent Henry Stanton (1846–1924) summarized the prevailing critical judgment regarding the historical priority of the Synoptic narratives:

The difference between the Synoptic representation of the person and the Ministry of Jesus and that in the Fourth Gospel is such that we are compelled to ask whether we can use them both. Most critics... give their preference to the Synoptics. Although they do not by any means regard them as fully trustworthy, they hold them to be so by comparison with the fourth evangelist. It is held that a presumption in favor of the Synoptic accounts is raised by their greater naturalness and lifelikeness, and the absence of the appearance of any such special doctrinal purpose as there is in the case of the Fourth Gospel, by which their character as narrators might be impaired. And it is held also that the result of a detailed comparison is to demonstrate their superiority to such an extent and in so many instances that, even where the best case can be made out for the Fourth Gospel, it is most probable that the others are in the right. (V. H. Stanton, The Gospels as Historical Documents, Part III: The Fourth Gospel [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1920], p. 209)

Similarly, in The Authority of the Bible (London: Nisbet & Co., 1928; Harper Torchbook ed., New York: Harper & Row, 1962), p. 215, C. H. Dodd—himself one of the twentieth century's foremost interpreters of Johannine tradition—distinguished sharply between the Fourth Gospel's spiritual depth and the Synoptics' historical primacy:

We may now say with confidence that for strictly historical material, with the minimum of subjective interpretation, we must not go to the Fourth Gospel. Its religious value stands beyond challenge, and it is the more fully appreciated when its contribution to our knowledge of the bare facts of the life of Jesus becomes a secondary interest. This is not to say that it makes no such contribution. But it is to the Synoptic Gospels that we must go if we wish to recover the oldest and purest tradition of the facts. (C. H. Dodd, The Authority of the Bible [London: Nisbet & Co., 1928; repr. New York: Harper & Row, 1962], p. 215)

History or Didactic Drama? G. H. C. Macgregor (1928)

In the introduction to his commentary The Gospel of John, Moffatt New Testament Commentary (London: Hodder & Stoughton / New York: Harper & Brothers, 1928), pp. x–xxvi, George H. C. Macgregor examined in detail both the Fourth Evangelist's literary dependence upon Mark and Luke and the systematic contrasts between Johannine drama and Synoptic history. Noting that B. H. Streeter (The Four Gospels: A Study of Origins [London: Macmillan, 1924]) found little convincing evidence for Johannine use of Matthew, Macgregor emphasized John's striking narrative contacts with Luke—including the sisters Martha and Mary (Luke 10:38–42 // John 11:1–2; 12:2–3), shared Passion details (Luke 22:34, 50; 23:22, 53 // John 13:38; 18:10; 19:1, 41), two angels at the tomb (Luke 24:4 // John 20:12), and Jerusalem as the site of the Easter evening appearance to the gathered disciples (Luke 24:36–40 // John 20:19–20; Macgregor 1928, pp. x–xi).

Comparing the two portraits across chronology, miracles, discourse form (contrasting Justin Martyr's celebrated remark in 1 Apology 14.5—"Short and pithy were the sayings that came from him, for he was no sophist"—with John's dialectical discourses), and human development, Macgregor concluded that the Fourth Evangelist wrote as a sacred dramatist and homilist rather than a chronicler (quoting also Friedrich von Hügel, "John, Gospel of St.," Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th ed., vol. 15 [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1911], pp. 452–458, and Clement of Alexandria in Eusebius, Hist. eccl. 6.14.7):

According to the Fourth Gospel, the Cleansing of the Temple occurred at the beginning of the ministry, while the Synoptics evidently regard it as an act of provocation which finally precipitated Jesus' death. That there were actually two "cleansings" will hardly be maintained... Once again John is influenced by dogmatic motives and by the desire to secure a suitable introductory incident to illustrate the theme, which is the key to the first section of the Gospel, that the new gospel of Christ is to supersede the old religion typified by the Temple. Having thus antedated the "Temple-cleansing," John is under the necessity of substituting another incident as the event which precipitated the denouement, and this he finds in the story of the raising of Lazarus, a miracle of which the Synoptics know nothing. (G. H. C. Macgregor, The Gospel of John [New York: Harper & Brothers, 1928], pp. xiv–xv)

In his attitude to miracles, John presents an interesting contrast to the Synoptics. As regards the type of miracle recorded it is noticeable that the cure of demoniacs, a class of miracle which not only, according to the Synoptics, was the most frequently performed, but also to the modern mind is the most credible, is entirely omitted... This is in line with John's tendency everywhere to heighten the miraculous. Those on whom the miracles are wrought have been ill for thirty-eight years, born blind, dead for no less than four days. Corresponding with this tendency is a new conception of Jesus' motive in performing miracles. According to the Synoptics it is because he is "moved with compassion" (Mark 1:41; 8:2); according to John, Jesus' "signs" are evidence of his divine power (and the more miraculous the more convincing the proof), and therefore "display his glory" (John 2:11). (pp. xv–xvi)

In the Synoptics we find practical precepts adapted to concrete situations. Jesus deals with life's great moral problems, the relation of Man to God and to his fellows; he speaks little of the mystery of his own Person and of his relation to the Father. His teaching deals almost exclusively with the question, What must one do to enter the Kingdom of God? In the Fourth Gospel, on the other hand, we find set discourses, abstract rather than practical in character, abounding in enigmatic allusions and the elucidation of misunderstandings, which often in themselves are not a little artificial, and bearing constantly on such subjects as Christ's own divinity, his relation to the Father, or on mysteries of faith... (p. xvii)

The Gospel may be well described as a didactic meditation on the drama of Christ's life. Indeed the author is essentially a dramatist rather than a historian. "The earthly life of Jesus in this Gospel appears as a dramatic interlude in the life of the Eternal Logos." ... In Jesus' discourses we have John's attempt to give his contemporaries a systematic summary of Christian teaching as he himself, under the inspiration of the Spirit of Jesus, conceived it, and his first readers, familiar with current Greek practice, would never suppose that Jesus' speeches were to be accepted as a verbatim report. Indeed so little careful is the author to distinguish between his own thoughts and those that he puts into the mouths of his characters, that it is sometimes impossible to tell where the speech which he is reporting ends and his own comment upon it begins. Note especially chapters 1 and 3. (pp. xxii, xxiv)

Henry Latimer Jackson, The Problem of the Fourth Gospel, Chapter 5 (1918)

In Chapter 5 ("The Johannine and the Synoptic Representation") of The Problem of the Fourth Gospel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1918), pp. 50–82, Henry Latimer Jackson marshaled a comprehensive comparison of the Synoptic and Johannine accounts across chronology, Passion dating, geography, John the Baptist, miracles, discourses, and the human portraiture of Jesus (incorporating inside single quotes the classic formulations of Adolf Jülicher, Paul Wernle, P. W. Schmiedel, James Drummond, F. C. Burkitt, and H. P. Forbes):

Overview, Chronology, and Scene of the Ministry

With the Synoptics, the scene is mainly laid in Galilee; with the Fourth Gospel it is largely transferred to Judaea and Jerusalem; in the former case the events are crowded into one short year, in the other, the Ministry is extended over three Passovers. In the one case the Jewish people are described with picturesque variety of type and class and section; not so in the other case, with "John" they dwindle down to Pharisees and Priests and rulers of the people; as for the Pharisees they have become the very core of unbelieving Judaism in its hostility to Jesus... And again, the difference between the Johannine and the Synoptic representations of the Passion, the Death, and the Resurrection is regarded as fundamental. For reasons such as these, there is widespread agreement that whatever be its interest and value as an early Christian document, the Fourth Gospel must be ruled out as a source for the Life of Jesus... Of our Four Canonical Gospels "John" is certainly the latest—and perhaps the latest by a long way; as for the remaining three, they are nearer to the events they purport to relate, and it is safe to say of the Synoptic tradition that it stretches back to Apostolic times and to the very days of Jesus. (pp. 50–52)

Christian thought is no longer fettered by outworn mechanical theories of inspiration and interpretation in the case of the Bible literature... Neither to the men themselves nor to their respective writings does infallibility attach. Neither he nor the Synoptics are infallible. If he corrects them and makes his alterations to them, it is exactly what two of them have already done with a third; Matthew and Luke have treated Mark with a very free hand. (pp. 52–53)

To turn to the Cleansing of the Temple. According to the Fourth Gospel it occurred at the beginning of the Ministry, while it is placed by the Synoptics at the close of the Ministry, and is evidently regarded by them as the decisive act which precipitated the Death of Jesus. Harmonists have struggled to escape the difficulty... The balance of probability is surely against the Johannine dating; for the position of the story in the Synoptics is natural, while in the case of our Gospel it has rather the effect of an anti-climax. (pp. 54–55)

Another instance of "violent alteration," as it would appear, is that of the respective datings of the Death-Day of Jesus. Take first the Synoptic representation. Jesus, it would appear, celebrates the Passover with the Twelve. They depart from the Upper Room; the scene changes from the Mount of Olives to "a place which was named Gethsemane"; quickly there follows the Arrest. As for the Crucifixion, it takes place the day after the Celebration of the Passover. Not so, says the Fourth Evangelist; he tells of a Supper partaken of by Jesus and his friends while nowhere stating that the number of the latter was limited to The Twelve. Far from identifying that Supper with the Paschal Meal, he is at pains to make it understood that the Passover lay still ahead; and that, when the night of its celebration had arrived, the body of Jesus was already in the tomb... in regard to the day of the month; the Synoptics assign it to the 15th of Nisan, "John" to the 14th. They are, accordingly, in flat contradiction in regard to date. (p. 55)

[Scene of the Ministry:] This, by the Synoptics, is laid in the Galilaean homeland of Jesus; and, recording certain journeys outside Galilaean territory, they have nothing to say of visits paid to Jerusalem save only the one which issued in his death. In sharp contrast is the representation of the Fourth Evangelist; for with him the scene on which Jesus moves during the period of his Messianic activity is Judaea, and in particular Jerusalem; but rarely does he appear in Galilee, and when there his stays are of brief duration. No wonder that the discrepancy is insisted on. (p. 58)

John the Baptist, Miracles, and Discourses

The contention here is that the Baptist who figures in the Fourth Gospel wears but slight if any resemblance to the Baptist of the Synoptic representation; that the two portraits are singularly unlike... it is possible that the real Baptist at no time definitely attached himself to the cause of Jesus, but went his own way and rushed to a self-invited fate. (p. 60)

We will observe in the first instance that one particular class of miracles is excluded by the Fourth Evangelist. In the case of the Synoptics there is frequent mention of demoniac-cures performed by Jesus; and, by the way, it is widely conceded that he did actually heal many a sufferer who, in the conception of the age, was possessed by an evil spirit. No such narratives occur in the Fourth Gospel; "John knows nothing whatsoever of the most frequent wonder-works of Jesus, the healing of demoniacs"; or rather, he declines to admit such Synoptic stories into his own Gospel... With the works of healing the effect is heightened; in one case the cure is performed from a considerable distance [John 4:46–54], in another blindness is from birth [John 9:1], in a third, it is emphatically said of the sick man that he had been no less than "thirty and eight years in his infirmity" [John 5:5]... the very climax is reached with the Raising of Lazarus... the narrative which, pointing to Bethany, suggests unmistakably that the corpse already four days in the tomb had seen corruption [John 11:17, 39]. It is true to say that "whereas the miracles of healing in the Synoptics are miracles of mercy and compassion, wrought because Jesus had sympathy with the sufferers, the miracles recorded by the Fourth Evangelist tend to the glory of him who wrought them. They are proofs, not of his humanity, but of his divinity." (pp. 62–66)

According to the Synoptics the demands of Jesus are for self-renunciation, for compassionate love, for a taking of one's self in hand, for work for others; his warnings are directed against the danger of riches, worldly desires and anxieties; above all he preaches about the Kingdom of God and the conditions of entrance therein. Not so in the Fourth Gospel; the preaching of the Kingdom recedes, while Jesus becomes the dialectician... In both cases he figures as teacher; in the Fourth Gospel the subject-matter of his teaching is [almost] exclusively himself. (pp. 68–69)

Jesus, as pictured in the earlier Gospels, whether he be speaking, preaching, or disputing, never has resort to dialectic skill, to the ambiguity of artifice, to a mystical style; on the contrary, there is utmost simplicity and clearness, a certain natural eloquence which owes far more to mental genius than to painfully acquired art. In the Fourth Gospel he disputes as the dialectician; ambiguous is his language and mystical his style; he deals to such an extent in obscurities that even very learned people are quite in the dark as to the real significance of many of his words. In the one case there are short and pregnant sayings, parables so full of beauty and of inward truth as to grip attention and to sink deep into the soul; in the other, the parabolic mode of teaching is practically absent. Here the question turns on conduct, rules of life, the Mosaic Law, and errors of the Jewish people; there the speaker is concerned with dogma, with metaphysics, with his own [person]. (p. 69)

There is an absence of variety in the manner of the discourses generally, no matter who the speaker may be; the several characters, that is, hold converse in Johannine phraseology, and without individuality whether of idea or speech; conversations are reported at length when, apparently, there was no third person at hand... "a Jesus who preached alternately in the manner of the Sermon on the Mount and of John 14–17 is a psychological impossibility." (pp. 70–71)

What is it that God looks for and what is alone decisive for life or death? The answer of the Fourth Gospel is this: believe in the Son of God who came down from heaven and believe that he is Jesus—an answer which has had a baneful effect on Christendom, for it is only too easy to make such a profession of belief without drawing nearer to God and becoming a better man. Very different is the answer of the Synoptic Jesus; with him, everything is contingent on that doing the Will of God which involves uprightness, brotherly love, trust in God, humility, yearnings for God's Kingdom; of those who do the Will of God he says that they are for him mother or sister or brother [Mark 3:35]. (p. 72)

"In the Johannine discourses... we feel that it is not the visible and audible Jesus who is speaking, but the Christ who is the life of the Church," and the only possible explanation is that the Fourth Gospel "is not history, but something else cast in a historical form." (p. 74, quoting E. F. Scott and F. C. Burkitt)

Contrasting Portraits of Jesus

He who looks down from the Synoptic canvas is assuredly true man. To drop metaphor, the Jesus of at any rate the Marcan representation has already reached manhood when he comes on the scene, and it is clear from the manner of the allusions that he shares the experiences which are common to the race. He is conscious of physical needs; the strain of continued action tells on him; stirred by emotions manifold he is moved to compassion by the spectacle of suffering and pain; he both wins and displays affection; capable of sternness he gives vent to wrath. Rebuff astonishes him, and he finds himself powerless to act [Mark 6:5–6]; he disclaims omniscience [Mark 13:32]; if he puts questions it is because he has need to be informed. Great spiritual crises are experienced by him, and the meaning of temptation is realized to the full. He cannot do without prayer; hence, seeking strength, he goes apart to be alone with God. Yet strength fails him; in Gethsemane deep terror seizes him, and he pleads as hoping for deliverance to the last. Bitter is the cry wrung from him in his dying moments. (pp. 75–76)

To turn from it to the portrait of the Johannine Christ... Majestic is the part played by him in the closing scenes; whether in the Garden, in the high priest's court or in the praetorium his [bearing] is stately and his speech serene. He "decides His own fate." But the Johannine representation does not stop short here; on the contrary, it is plain that the regal personage depicted transcends mere manhood. He manifests a celestial glory. He knows all men as knowing what is in man [John 2:24–25]... Pre-existent as he claims to be, he is conceived of as "the Word" that was with God from all eternity. (p. 78)

When every allowance has been made for powers of adaptation and varied environments, it is impossible to believe that the historic Jesus was really accustomed to discourse after the manner of the Johannine Christ. The former lives and moves in the Synoptic Gospels. The modern student cannot but feel that to turn from the Synoptics to the Fourth Gospel is to breathe another atmosphere, to be transported to another world. The contrast is, indeed, sharp... "Another world." "The world, to a certainty, of Greek life and thought"; the world of Asia Minor, of Ephesus. (p. 82)

Twentieth-Century Critical Survey: Wilbert Francis Howard (1931)

In The Fourth Gospel in Recent Criticism and Interpretation (London: Epworth Press, 1931; 4th ed. rev. C. K. Barrett, 1955; repr. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2009), pp. 3–33, 128–141, Wilbert Francis Howard documented how deeply the critical recognition of Synoptic–Johannine divergence had entered mainstream biblical scholarship—surveying standard one-volume commentaries (A. E. Brooke in Peake's Commentary on the Bible, 1919; Walter Lock in A New Commentary on Holy Scripture, ed. Charles Gore, 1928; A. E. Garvie in The Abingdon Bible Commentary, 1929) alongside major monographs by Benjamin Wisner Bacon (The Fourth Gospel in Research and Debate, 1910), F. C. Burkitt (The Gospel History and Its Transmission, 1906, pp. 227–231), James Moffatt (An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, 1911), Jean Réville (Le quatrième évangile, 1901), P. W. Schmiedel (Encyclopaedia Biblica, vol. 2, 1901), C. H. Dodd (1928), and the Semitic philologist Gustaf Dalman (Jesus–Jeshua: Studies in the Gospels, trans. Paul P. Levertoff [London: SPCK, 1929], pp. 86–106):

The day has passed when the student could simply assume that it is a direct historical narrative of the ministry and words of Jesus from the pen of the apostle John, and that any other theory of its character and origin is the product of "unbelieving criticism." Even the unprofessional Bible student entrusted with the preaching of the word knows that this is not so... For most of us the essence of the problem can be put in one short sentence: how far is it possible for us to use the Fourth Gospel as a reliable witness to the earthly life and teaching of Jesus Christ? (W. F. Howard, The Fourth Gospel in Recent Criticism and Interpretation [London: Epworth Press, 1931], p. 3)

The reason for the widespread abandonment of the full apostolic authorship of the Gospel is the clearer recognition that the external evidence is indecisive. It is not until we reach the last quarter of the second century that Irenaeus provides us with our first unambiguous witness in support of the traditional theory... We are without any definite evidence to show that this Gospel was attributed to John by name in any writing before the time of Irenaeus. (p. 7)

[Summarizing F. C. Burkitt, The Gospel History and Its Transmission, 1906:] The Fourth Gospel is written to prove the reality of Jesus Christ. But the Evangelist was no historian; ideas, not events, were to him the true realities, and if we go to his work to learn the course of events we shall only be disappointed in our search... The impossibility of finding a place for the raising of Lazarus in the historical framework of Mark decides against the historicity of that story... After describing the debates reported in chaps. v. and viii., Dr. Burkitt concludes: "It is quite inconceivable that the historical Jesus of the Synoptic Gospels could have argued and quibbled with opponents as he is represented to have done in the Fourth Gospel. The only possible explanation is that the work is not history, but something else cast in historical form." (p. 25)

"The Fourth Gospel is not a faithful historical account of the life and teaching of Jesus." Such is the blunt verdict of M. Jean Réville at the close of his critical analysis. Dr. P. W. Schmiedel dismisses the matter with a mere wave of the hand: "A book which begins by declaring Jesus to be the Logos of God and ends by representing a cohort of Roman soldiers as falling to the ground at the majesty of His appearance (John 18:6), and by representing 100 pounds of ointment as having been used at His embalming (John 19:39), ought by these facts alone to be spared such a misunderstanding of its true character as would be implied in supposing that it meant to be an historical work." (p. 128)

Reasons have often been suggested for the Evangelist's choice, or rejection, of the material at his disposal. Thus of the many signs which Jesus wrought he selected, amongst others, four which serve to enhance the superhuman power of Jesus: the nature miracle at Cana in Galilee, the healing of a man who had been a cripple for thirty-eight years and of another man who had been blind from birth, and above all, the raising of a man who had been four days in the tomb. On the other hand, it is easy to find plausible grounds for some of the omissions. Thus, the divine dignity of our Lord might seem to be compromised by the story of the temptation, the agony in the garden, and the cry of abandonment on the cross. Polemical or apologetic aims may have led to silence regarding the submission of Jesus to baptism by John, and the institution of the Eucharist. (p. 132)

The great authority of Gustaf Dalman [Jesus–Jeshua, 1929] can be cited for the Synoptic as against the Johannine presentation [of the Last Supper]. His explanation is that the Fourth Evangelist knew that the words recorded by the Synoptists in connection with the distribution of the bread and of the wine were actually spoken, but that he suppressed them in his account of the events of the last evening, transferring them to the discourse in Capernaum [John 6:51–58]. He did this for a double reason. He wished to emphasize "that it is the Person of our Lord that is of the greatest value to humanity." He also feared that, as the disciples could not distinguish between spirit and flesh (John 6:60–63), the words if recorded in their original form would give rise to more serious misunderstandings, which would put the teaching and behavior of Christians in an unfavorable light. Having, then, transferred words which were originally spoken at the Last Supper as a Passover meal to another place, to show that what our Lord said to His disciples on that last night had nothing to do with this Jewish rite, he was compelled "to push back this last evening for one day, so that the Passover meal would have taken place after the death of Jesus. To the author, to whom the spiritual possession of God's grace and truth in Jesus was central, this method did not seem wrong." Dalman naturally observes with reference to the influence of motive upon narrative, "If this be the case, it is a serious warning to us not to put too much weight upon the Johannine presentation of the outward order of events of the earthly life of our Lord." (p. 139)

Critical opinion is not so generally favorable to the Johannine dating of the cleansing of the Temple. This question is bound up with another—that is, the difficult problem of the raising of Lazarus. The Synoptic Gospels are silent upon this tremendous miracle, and for them, it was the cleansing of the Temple that provoked the bitter hostility of the high-priestly group. With John, the raising of Lazarus focuses the enmity of the authorities at Jerusalem. (p. 141)