NTcanon.comCore NT Series
Case for the Core New Testament
Lukan Priority
Issues with Mark
Issues with Matthew
Issues with John
Luke Primacy
Other Issues

Issues with John

John and Philosophy

Philosophical and Religious Matrices of the Fourth Gospel

From the opening cadences of its Prologue—"In the beginning was the Word [Logos]" (John 1:1)—the Fourth Gospel situates the story of Jesus within a conceptual universe markedly distinct from that of Matthew, Mark, and Luke. For more than two centuries, critical scholarship has investigated how the Fourth Evangelist mediated between Jewish scriptural monotheism and the philosophical and religious currents of the Greco-Roman East at the turn of the second century CE. Four intersecting backgrounds have stood at the center of that inquiry:

  1. Hellenistic-Jewish Logos Philosophy (Philo of Alexandria): In first-century Alexandria, the Jewish exegete and philosopher Philo (c. 20 BCE–c. 50 CE) harmonized Mosaic revelation with Middle Platonism and Stoicism through the mediating figure of the divine Logos ("Word" and "Reason"). Drawing simultaneously on Stoic conceptions of immanent cosmic Reason, Plato's intelligible realm of archetypal Forms (De Opificio Mundi 16–25), and biblical personifications of divine Wisdom (Prov 8:22–31; Sir 24:1–23; Wis 7:22–8:1), Philo described the Logos as God's "firstborn Son" (prōtogonos; De Confusione Linguarum 146), heavenly high priest (De Somniis 1.215), creative instrument through whom the universe was framed (De Cherubim 127), and even a subordinate "second God" (deuteros theos; Quaestiones et Solutiones in Genesin 2.62). Strikingly, in De Somniis 1.228–230 Philo explicitly distinguishes the supreme God—designated with the Greek definite article (ho theos)—from the Logos, designated anarthrously as theos ("divine" or "God" in a derivative, qualitative sense), anticipating the exact grammatical distinction of John 1:1b–c (ho logos ēn pros ton theon, kai theos ēn ho logos).
  2. Biblical Wisdom, Torah Homiletics, and Targumic Memra Traditions: Alongside Alexandrian philosophy, twentieth- and twenty-first-century scholars have explored deeply Jewish matrices for Johannine thought. In his classic study The Interpretation of the Fourth Gospel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1953), pp. 54–73, 263–285, C. H. Dodd weighed Rabbinic Judaism, Philo, and the Corpus Hermeticum side by side, arguing that John fused Hellenistic-Jewish Logos speculation with Palestinian scriptural traditions in order to communicate with educated Greek-speaking readers. Peder Borgen demonstrated that both John 6 and the Prologue (John 1:1–18) exhibit recognizable patterns of Jewish synagogue homiletics and midrashic exposition of Genesis 1:1–5 alongside Philonic thought (Peder Borgen, Bread from Heaven: An Exegetical Study of the Concept of Manna in the Gospel of John and the Writings of Philo, NovTSup 10 [Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1965]; Borgen, "Observations on the Targumic Character of the Prologue of John," New Testament Studies 16 [1970]: 288–295). More recently, John Ronning (The Jewish Targums and John's Logos Theology [Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, 2010]) has argued extensively that the Aramaic Targumic circumlocution "the Word [Memra] of the Lord" stands behind Johannine Christological titles, whereas commentators such as Craig S. Keener (The Gospel of John: A Commentary, 2 vols. [Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, 2003], 1:339–363) emphasize that even where Jewish Wisdom, Torah, and Memra traditions supplied foundational concepts, the Evangelist deliberately selected the Greek philosophical term Logos as a cultural bridge to the wider Mediterranean world.
  3. Hermeticism and Hellenistic Mysticism: Collected in the Corpus Hermeticum (philosophical-religious dialogues composed in Greek in Roman Egypt primarily between the first and third centuries CE, though incorporating older Greco-Egyptian speculative traditions), Hermetic tractates such as Poimandres (CH 1) and On Rebirth (CH 13) employ striking dualistic and revelatory vocabulary—"light" and "life," "truth," the creative "Word" (Logos), knowledge (gnōsis) of the Father, and spiritual "rebirth" from above—that closely parallels Johannine discourse, as analyzed by C. H. Dodd (1953, pp. 10–53) and subsequent historians of Hellenistic religion.
  4. Early Second-Century Gnosticism and Proto-Orthodox Hesitation: Whether the Fourth Evangelist wrote in polemical opposition to proto-Gnostic docetism (cf. 1 John 4:2–3) or shared conceptual vocabulary with nascent Gnostic movements, external history confirms that Gnostic teachers were among the very first authors to adopt and comment upon the Gospel of John. According to Hippolytus of Rome, the Alexandrian teacher Basilides (fl. c. 125–135 CE) appealed directly to John 1:9 and John 2:4 in expounding his cosmogony (Hippolytus, Refutatio omnium haeresium 7.22.4; 7.27.5). Within the Valentinian school, Ptolemaeus composed a detailed allegorical exposition of John 1:1–14 preserved by Irenaeus (Adversus haereses 1.8.5), and Heracleon (c. 170 CE) authored the earliest known commentary on the Fourth Gospel, substantial fragments of which survive in Origen's Commentary on John. Conversely, within proto-orthodox circles prior to Irenaeus (c. 180 CE), reception of the Fourth Gospel remained cautious—and around 200 CE the learned Roman presbyter Gaius (together with critics nicknamed the "Alogi" by Epiphanius, Panarion 51) rejected the Gospel's apostolicity outright, attributing it to Cerinthus and pointing to its chronological contradictions with the Synoptic Gospels (Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica 2.25.6; 3.28.1–2; 6.20.3).

The scholarly studies and classic critical excerpts surveyed below trace these philosophical, Hermetic, Philonic, and Gnostic dimensions of the Fourth Gospel.

Early Gnostic Reception and Roman Skepticism: Culpepper (1998) and Bruce (1988)

Modern historians of the Johannine corpus and the New Testament canon emphasize how deeply the Fourth Gospel's early association with Gnostic exegesis shaped its slow canonical reception among mainstream second-century churches. In The Canon of Scripture (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 1988), p. 148, F. F. Bruce observes that of the four canonical Gospels, John required the longest period to gain universal recognition among catholic Christians precisely because Gnostic schools claimed it almost from its initial circulation—pointing to Basilides (c. 130 CE; cf. Hippolytus, Ref. 7.22.4, 7.27.5) for the earliest attested citations of John and to the Valentinian teacher Heracleon (c. 170–180 CE; preserved in Origen, Comm. Jo.) for its earliest commentary.

R. Alan Culpepper develops this reception history in The Gospel and Letters of John, Interpreting Biblical Texts (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1998), pp. 288–289. Tracing the Valentinian school founded in Rome by Valentinus (c. 100–175 CE), Culpepper notes that while church fathers prior to Irenaeus (c. 180 CE) used the Fourth Gospel only tentatively, Valentinus's disciples Ptolemaeus (Irenaeus, Adv. Haer. 1.8.5) and Heracleon treated John as an authoritative scripture alongside works such as the Valentinian Gospel of Truth (Nag Hammadi Codex I,3), even as Marcion restricted his gospel canon to an edited form of Luke and Tatian combined all four Gospels into his Diatessaron (c. 170 CE). Particularly revealing, Culpepper argues, is the reaction of the orthodox Roman scholar and presbyter Gaius at the end of the second century: opposing Montanist prophets from Asia Minor who based their Paraclete claims on John 14–16, Gaius challenged the apostolic authorship of the Fourth Gospel by cataloging its narrative discrepancies against Matthew, Mark, and Luke:

Gaius is significant because he shows that the authority of John was not so firmly established that it could not be challenged by one of the leaders of the church. The form of his argument is also telling: he sought to discredit the Gospel of John by showing that it contradicted the synoptic Gospels, which by implication served as the standard by which a gospel could be judged. (R. Alan Culpepper, The Gospel and Letters of John [Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1998], p. 289)

Alexandria, Papyri, and Gnosticism: W. F. Howard (1931) and C. K. Barrett (1955)

In The Fourth Gospel in Recent Criticism and Interpretation (London: Epworth Press, 1931), p. 23, British Methodist scholar Wilbert Francis Howard summarized Ernest Findlay Scott's landmark thesis (The Fourth Gospel: Its Purpose and Theology, 1906) regarding the Evangelist's translation of early Christian faith into Greek philosophical categories:

The Fourth Gospel: Its Purpose and Theology (1906), the first of many books by which Dr. E. F. Scott has enriched the study of the New Testament, made an immediate impression in this country, which remains after a quarter of a century... The indecisive character of the external evidence drives us to the Gospel itself. By assuming a date early in the second century, and an author who was in no sense an apostle or contemporary of Jesus, Dr. Scott expounds the Gospel as a reinterpretation of Christianity to a larger world of Hellenic culture and the exigencies of controversy. In this narrative we are to recognize the work of one who identified the eternal Christ of inward religious experience with the Jesus of history, and who went back to the historical record to understand its deeper meaning, and to complete it and interpret it in the light of all the church had learnt by faith concerning the person and work of the exalted Lord. (W. F. Howard, The Fourth Gospel in Recent Criticism and Interpretation [London: Epworth Press, 1931], p. 23)

When C. K. Barrett revised and expanded Howard's volume for its fourth edition (The Fourth Gospel in Recent Criticism and Interpretation, 4th ed., rev. C. K. Barrett [London: Epworth Press, 1955; repr. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2009], Part II, pp. 165, 170), two major papyrological discoveries in Egypt—Papyrus Rylands Greek 457 (𝔓52, containing fragments of John 18:31–33, 37–38) and the unknown gospel fragments of Papyrus Egerton 2 (published in 1935)—had reshaped the debate over Johannine origins. Summarizing J. N. Sanders's monograph The Fourth Gospel in the Early Church: Its Origin and Influence on Christian Theology up to Irenaeus (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1943), Barrett highlighted four converging arguments advanced for an Alexandrian rather than Ephesian provenance: (1) 𝔓52 and Papyrus Egerton 2 attest circulation of the Gospel in Egypt prior to c. 150 CE, whereas acquaintance with John among the Apostolic Fathers (including Ignatius) remains uncertain; (2) Alexandrian Gnostics such as Basilides and Valentinus were the earliest known users of the Gospel; (3) Alexandria—home both to Philo and to circles producing the Corpus Hermeticum—offered the most natural intellectual environment for a Christian Logos theology combining anti-docetic and anti-Judaic polemic; and (4) the early heterodox reputation of Egyptian Christianity would readily explain why proto-orthodox writers elsewhere hesitated to adopt the Fourth Gospel (Barrett, in Howard and Barrett 1955, p. 165). Assessing the broader mid-century scholarly consensus on Gnosticism, Barrett concluded:

Most modern writers are agreed that there exists a connection of some kind between the Fourth Gospel and Gnosticism. This seems to be affirmed both by the contents of the Gospel, and by its external history, in which it was first used by the Gnostic heretics themselves, and subsequently adopted as a major weapon in the armoury of those who, like Irenaeus and Hippolytus, fought the Gnostics and drove them out of the Church... it becomes increasingly difficult to deny that John was aware of the terms of Gnostic thought. It remains of course possible that his relation to this kind of thought was negative—that is, he knew it, but disliked, rejected and opposed it. (C. K. Barrett, in Howard and Barrett 1955, p. 170)

Hellenism, Mystery Terminology, Gnosticism, and Philo: G. H. C. Macgregor (1928)

In the introduction to his commentary The Gospel of John, Moffatt New Testament Commentary (London: Hodder & Stoughton / New York: Harper & Brothers, 1928), pp. xxvi–xxxix, George H. C. Macgregor (1892–1963) situated the Fourth Gospel in early second-century Ephesus as an intentional translation of the Christian message for a predominantly Gentile church severed from its original Palestinian environment. Reviewing contemporary polemical theories—including Wilhelm Baldensperger's hypothesis (Der Prolog des vierten Evangeliums [Freiburg: J. C. B. Mohr, 1898]) that the Evangelist targeted a rival sect of John the Baptist's disciples (cf. Acts 18:25; 19:3–4; Pseudo-Clementine Recognitions 1.54, 60)—Macgregor argued that while Baptist apologetics and Hellenistic Mystery terminology ("rebirth," sacramental participation) appear in John 3 and John 6, the Evangelist consistently spiritualizes and ethicizes them ("What gives life is the Spirit: flesh is of no avail at all," John 6:63; Macgregor 1928, pp. xxx–xxxii).

On the Gospel's relationship to nascent Gnosticism (citing Ernst von Dobschütz, Christian Life in the Primitive Church [London: Williams & Norgate, 1904], on Gnostic intellectualism) and to Philonic Logos philosophy, Macgregor steered a middle course between viewing John as a Gnostic treatise and viewing it solely as anti-Gnostic polemic, while affirming the Prologue's philosophical debt to Alexandrian Judaism (note that where Macgregor wrote "Greek Neoplatonism" in 1928, modern historians of philosophy classify Philo's first-century synthesis as Middle Platonism):

[The Fourth] Gospel sets out to interpret the Christian story and Christian experience to the new world of Hellenism by translating the Gospel into a form intelligible to Greek modes of thought... Whether or no the actual key to the understanding of the Gospel is to be found in "a transmutation of Jewish and Christian ideas into their Greek equivalents," John's great achievement was to transplant the Gospel of Jesus into a new soil before its roots had time to wither. (G. H. C. Macgregor, The Gospel of John [New York: Harper & Brothers, 1928], p. xxix)

As regards the Fourth Gospel's relation to Gnosticism two extreme positions have been taken up. It has by some been definitely claimed as a product of Gnostic Christianity, and was indeed referred, in antiquity, to the Gnostic Cerinthus as its author; by others it has been as definitely regarded as a polemic against the rising heresy. The truth is midway between the extremes. Tinged with Gnostic influences John certainly is. He shares with the Gnostics a certain dualism in his conception of both man and the world, and a certain intellectualism in his conception of faith and in his insistence upon the necessity of "knowing" God. There is a dualism which envisages a deep division set between light and darkness (John 1:5), the children of God (John 1:13) and those of the devil (John 8:44), spirit and flesh (John 3:6), the Church and the world (John 17:16)... (pp. xxxiii–xxxiv)

But it was Philo, the famous Jewish thinker of Alexandria (20 B.C.–A.D. 50), who combined these Greek and Hebrew conceptions and brought the idea of the Logos to its fullest development. He took over the main Stoic conception, but so identified it with Plato's idea of the "Good" and the Hebrew thought of the "Wisdom" of God, that instead of being merely immanent in creation the Logos for him became endowed with an independent existence. In the Philonic "Logos" the Greek idea of immanent reason is combined with the Hebrew idea of divine creative-energy and self-revelation. Yet Philo's Jewish faith forbade the identification of the Logos with the Deity Himself, and it therefore sometimes appears as a kind of "second God" independent of but subordinate to the God of the Old Testament, though Philo's monotheism makes it unlikely that this assertion of the existence of a second divine agent is intended in anything more than a figurative sense. There is in fact an inevitable clash between the primary Greek conception and the demands of Hebrew monotheism, an antinomy which is never wholly reconciled. (p. xxxvi)

Now John was no doubt impregnated with Old Testament thought; he may well have been influenced by the Targumic idea of the Memra (though it is uncertain whether that usage was earlier than his time); but in so far as the Prologue is quite clearly a philosophically conceived attempt to build a bridge between Greek and Hebrew modes of thought, John must be pronounced indebted for his Logos-doctrine to Philo, who was the first to attempt such a synthesis by popularizing the term "Logos." ... John is primarily concerned not with the Word as a philosophical principle but with the Word made flesh and manifested in human history in the whole life of Jesus Christ. (pp. xxxvi–xxxvii)

The Logos-doctrine is everywhere presupposed in the body of the Gospel, though the actual use of the term ceases with the Prologue. It is this that explains the insistence on the omniscience and omnipotence of Jesus, his inviolability, the minimizing of the purely human elements in his personality, his continual reference to his own Person as the source of life, and in particular such claims to pre-existence as we have in John 1:30, John 17:5, John 8:58. Finally, though the term "Logos" is never used of Christ in the body of the Gospel, its content reappears under the categories of "Truth," "Light," and "Life." (p. xxxviii)

Ernest Findlay Scott, The Historical and Religious Value of the Fourth Gospel (1909)

In The Historical and Religious Value of the Fourth Gospel (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1909), Scottish-Canadian New Testament scholar Ernest Findlay Scott (1868–1954) distilled for a wider readership the critical arguments of his larger 1906 T&T Clark monograph. Across pages 18–82, Scott examines how the Fourth Evangelist's adoption of Philonic and Stoic Logos philosophy simultaneously enabled Christianity to take root in Greek thought and reshaped the historical portrait of Jesus:

Subordinate Polemical and Ecclesial Aims

When we look below the surface of the fourth Gospel we seem to discover clear traces of this interest in the contemporary life of the church. Several of the more striking peculiarities of the Gospel are not capable of explanation until we read it not only as a history of Jesus, but as a tract for the times called forth by the practical requirements of the second century. (p. 18)

It is impossible to avoid the inference that the evangelist, writing at a time when the synagogue was in strong opposition to the church, took occasion to read back into the past the conflict of the present. His Gospel became, in one of its aspects, a reply to the Jewish antagonists, whose arguments were more dangerous than any others to the progress of the Christian mission. (p. 20)

We know that the First Epistle of John (a kindred writing, which comes to us from the same school, if not from the same hand) is directed against certain heretical teachers. These appear to have been precursors of the later Gnostics, who denied the reality of Christ's appearance and death, and sought to resolve his message into a vague philosophical system. It is highly probable that the same type of heretical teaching is combated in the Gospel. The writer goes back to the earthly life of Jesus, and follows it step by step through its earthly progress. He lays stress on details which serve to illustrate the Lord's humanity. He offers solemn testimony to the material fact of the death upon the Cross. The whole Gospel centers on the thesis that the Word was made flesh,—that the divine nature has imparted itself to men through a human life. But while the evangelist is thus strongly opposed to Gnosticism, there is reason to believe that he has himself been touched by Gnostic influences. He makes frequent use of well-known Gnostic watch-words; he draws a Gnostic distinction between the two classes of men,—the earthly and the spiritual, the children of darkness and the children of light; with all his insistence on the reality of the Saviour's life he never loses sight of its ideal significance. This twofold attitude to the Gnostic speculations is one of the chief problems of the Gospel. In order to solve it fully we should require to know something of the personality of the writer and of the particular circumstances in which he wrote. (pp. 21–23)

Living at a time when the unity of the church was in danger, and when various abuses were creeping into its life and sacraments, he sought to remind it of its true character. He reads back into the gospel history the conditions of his own day, in order to submit them to the Master's judgment. Jesus himself becomes the counselor and legislator of his church... Under the form of a biography of Jesus it deals with problems and difficulties which did not arise until after his death. It bears a constant reference not only to the events which it narrates but to the situation of the church in the early part of the second century. (pp. 25–26)

Transition to Greek Philosophy and the Philonic Logos

Judaism and Christianity had come to open quarrel; and the younger religion had to seek its future in the great Gentile world, to which its beliefs and ideals and traditions were all strange. It was evident that if the church was to survive and to maintain itself as a living power, its whole message had to be re-interpreted. Some expression must be found for the revelation in Christ, which would set it free from its mere local and accidental elements and give it a meaning for Gentiles in the second century as it had had for Jews in the first. Our Gospel was written in those years of critical transition. The task which the evangelist laid on himself was that of interpreting to a new time and translating into the terms of a different culture, the truth as it was in Christ. (pp. 28–29)

The Christian theology is presented in the fourth Gospel under Greek forms of thought. Paul was a Jew of Tarsus, one of the centers of Greek philosophical culture; and a Hellenic influence has been traced in not a few of his speculations. But the prevailing colour of his thought is Jewish. He was trained in the Rabbinical schools and borrowed from them the theological ideas under which he explained the new message. The fourth evangelist—though almost certainly a Jew—had entered deeply into the spirit of Greek philosophy. In his endeavor to set forth the inner meaning of the Christian revelation, he discards the Jewish forms, which were unintelligible to the wider audience he has in view. In a far more radical sense than Paul, he re-interprets the message. (pp. 31–32)

Greek philosophy was chiefly represented in the first and second centuries by Stoicism; and the central doctrine of Stoicism was that of the Logos, or immanent Reason of the world. An attempt had already been made by Philo, a Jewish thinker of Alexandria, to reconcile Greek philosophy with the Old Testament on the ground of this Stoic doctrine. The Greek term "Logos" signifies "word" as well as "reason"; and Philo had availed himself of this double meaning. Into the Old Testament allusions to the creative and revealing word of God he had read the philosophical conception of the Logos; and had thus evolved that theory that within the being of God there was a secondary divine principle, the Word or Logos, which was His agent in the creation and government of the world. (pp. 32–33)

We must needs admit that in his endeavor to represent Jesus as at once man and incarnate Logos, the evangelist falls into many inconsistencies. Not only so, but he divests the historical life of much of its meaning and its true grandeur, in order to bring it into conformity with the Logos idea. We miss from his narrative some of the most striking episodes of the Synoptic story,—for example, the Baptism, the Temptation, the Agony, the Cry from the Cross. These could not be reconciled with the theory of the Logos and had therefore to be omitted... The prayers of Jesus cease to be true appeals for God's help and guidance. He is himself one with the Father and knows beforehand that his prayer is sure of fulfillment. As many things are omitted, so there are certain features added which impair the human reality of the portrait. (pp. 36–37)

Replacement of the Kingdom of God and Historical Assessment

The message of Jesus is concerned with the coming age, or kingdom of God; but the kingdom itself is identified with its chief blessing. Jesus can speak, almost in the same sentence, of "entering into the kingdom" and of "inheriting eternal life" [cf. Mark 10:17, 23]. The fourth evangelist takes advantage of this equivalence of the two terms and discards the idea of the kingdom altogether. It was related to hopes and beliefs that were specifically Jewish, and he replaces it by the more general conception of life. (p. 50)

Writing in a new century, for a people of alien race and culture, the evangelist goes back to the teaching of Jesus; but he does not simply reproduce it as it had been handed down. He translates it into new language; he interprets it with the aid of later theological forms; he brings it into relation to contemporary problems and interests, which had not yet emerged in the Master's own lifetime. Literally considered the message is different from that which had come down in the tradition. The words attributed to Jesus had not actually fallen from his lips, and the whole picture of his earthly life and surroundings is in many respects altered. (pp. 72–73)

He [the author] availed himself of categories of thought, unknown to the primitive age, which were derived mainly from the philosophies of Greece. These new categories were in many ways well fitted to express Christian ideas; but it cannot be denied that something was lost by the adoption of them. The teaching of Jesus became abstract and mystical, instead of simple and direct. An appeal was made to the intellect more than to the underlying instincts of the moral and religious life. (p. 76)

It asserted itself heir to five centuries of Greek thinking. It was acclimatized in the general culture of the time and penetrated it more and more with its own spirit. To the fourth evangelist, more than to any other teacher, the church was indebted for the mighty progress of the next three centuries. He transplanted the new religion from its Jewish soil into another, where it could take deep root and send out its branches freely... It is true that in this endeavor to portray Jesus, in his earthly ministry, as the ever-living Christ, the evangelist has modified and idealized the facts. As a work of history his Gospel is secondary to the Synoptic records, and its evidence must always be sifted and controlled by means of them. (pp. 77–78, 82)

Henry Latimer Jackson, The Problem of the Fourth Gospel (1918)

In The Problem of the Fourth Gospel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1918), pp. 87–133, Cambridge scholar Henry Latimer Jackson (1851–1926) examined how the Fourth Gospel's ambivalent relationship to early Gnostic dualism and Alexandrian Logos speculation helps date its composition to approximately 100–125 CE—prior to the fully developed systems of Basilides and Valentinus, yet subsequent to all three Synoptic Gospels—and evaluated internal signs of redactional layering within the Johannine school (note that single quotation marks inside Jackson's prose cite earlier critical authorities recorded in his footnotes, including E. F. Scott, Adolf Jülicher, and A. S. Peake):

Gnosticism and the Self-Dating of the Fourth Gospel

We now address ourselves more particularly to one of "the two main tendencies in the early Church which lie near the main current of its historic development," viz. Gnosticism. It is, of course, impossible in these pages to treat in detail of successive stages in and the many phases of—to repeat from a previous chapter—"the boldest and grandest syncretism the world has ever beheld," and nothing more shall be attempted than a very general and bare outline of Gnosticism in its leading features. Of the Gnostic sects it has been said that they "were the result of the contact of Christian principles with the current ideas of the first century," every Gnostic system being "an attempt to blend Christianity with the theosophical speculations of the age"; "in a sense, however, Gnosticism is more ancient than the Church, being a philosophy of religion which seeks in the end to explain every cultus"; it is then suggested that "the great test to which primitive Christianity was exposed from the outside world was not so much the danger of succumbing to persecution, as of adapting itself to the popular philosophies of the heathen and Jewish world." (pp. 87–88)

As the principle [that matter is essentially evil] was pressed to its logical conclusion, it was maintained that by no possibility could a world essentially evil be the creation of the supreme Deity; and hence the work of creation was referred to an inferior being, while it was argued that of communication between the supreme God and the material evil world there could be none whatever. Intermediate agencies, aeons, emanations of the Deity, were accordingly conceived of. The conception being scouted that the highest of the emanations of the Father could take upon himself a material body, there came flat denials of the reality of the Incarnation, protests, in many forms, against the true humanity, the real suffering, of Jesus; in a word Docetism. There was indeed, so it was allowed by some [such as Cerinthus; cf. Irenaeus, Adv. Haer. 1.26.1], a man Jesus upon whom the superior aeon Christ had descended at the Baptism, but only to desert him at the Crucifixion; others, again [such as Basilides according to Irenaeus, Adv. Haer. 1.24.4], alleged that it was really Simon the Cyrenian who was crucified and by mistake, while the real Jesus looked on and smiled. Whatever the explanations offered, they alike show "how rooted was the idea that God could not possibly have anything to do immediately with matter, or with the sufferings of a material universe; if He seemed to make such contact, it was only in appearance. The suffering Christ was a phantom; not a hair of his head was touched, let alone a bone being broken." (pp. 88–89)

Now, there are clear indications of the spread of more or less developed Gnostic tendencies both in the admittedly genuine Pauline Epistles and in those which may or may not be traceable to Paul himself. Thus in the case of the Colossian heresy, which has "been pronounced to contain all the essential elements of a Gnostic system"; the situation is less clear in the so-called Epistle to the Ephesians, yet there are hints at errors similar to those which prevailed at the neighboring Colossae; as for the Pastoral Epistles, they suggest that need had arisen at Ephesus to deal with the question of asceticism and to draw plain distinctions between true knowledge and knowledge which is "falsely so called" [1 Tim 6:20]. Nor is there room for doubt that, whether he be Paul or not, the author of the Epistles to Timothy was confronted with, at all events, the germs of Docetism when, 1 Tim 3:16, he points emphatically to Jesus as "manifested in the flesh." (pp. 89–90)

We now turn to our Gospel. As we have seen already, it was not only commented on by the Gnostic Heracleon, but held in estimation by Basilides... There are two extreme positions. In the one case our Gospel has been definitely claimed for Gnosticism; in the other it is said to be characterized throughout by a pronounced antagonism to Gnostic modes of thought. The truth, however, does not appear to lie in either quarter, and it is far more reasonable to decide that, in some degree sympathetic, it also tells plainly of a discriminating mind. That it is not untinged by Gnostic influences might be admitted; its author has occasional resort to a terminology in use in Gnostic circles, he makes room for an "intellectualism" of a certain kind, elements of dualism are perceptible in his conceptions, the idealized portrait of his Christ is suggestive of a Docetism from which he himself is not altogether free. On the other hand it must be as readily admitted that, by no means blind to momentous issues, he fastens on and repudiates errors detected by him in Gnostic doctrines which were making their appearance in his day. (p. 90)

We are led to the conclusion that our Gospel places us in a day when Basilides and Valentinus had yet to elaborate their systems, and that accordingly it is prior to the year A.D. 135 or thereabouts... Whatever the identity of the Evangelist, he writes at a date later than the latest of the Synoptics; and here we bear in mind the uncertainty which attaches to the dating of the Matthaean and the Lucan Gospels. The very fact of his dependence on the Synoptics is an argument in favour of the theory that some time had elapsed since their publication. Nor is this all; the world in which he places us is not diverse only in locality, but in conceptions which suggest an after day. The One of whom he tells is not so much the Jesus of the Synoptic representation as the Christ of the experience of his own inmost soul. Were our search to end at this point the conclusion would be reasonable that, although no precise date can be fixed, our Gospel can be safely assigned to the period A.D. 100–125. (pp. 91–92)

Composition, Redaction, and Historical Assessment

The Fourth Evangelist is, in all probability, not the Apostle John;—who, then, is he? Conjectures are numerous... Whoever he was, the Evangelist was assuredly a Jew. By birth and early training he was, in all likelihood, a Jew of Palestine who, at some period or other, had quitted his Palestinian home, and after much travelling, had found himself on the soil of Asia Minor; in the event he settled down at Ephesus... Beyond all question he was a man of soul and brain, of a contemplative turn of mind, in touch with Greek philosophy and versed in Alexandrine speculation, a philosopher and a theologian. He may indeed convey the impression that he had actually been eye- and ear-witness of at all events some of the events and scenes told of by him in the pages of his work. Yet the temptation is now and again strong to say of it that the evidences of dependence are so many and so convincing "as to justify or even compel the inference that the author is not an eye-witness supplementing the Synoptic account by his own minute remembrances, but a writer somewhat remote from the events" which he purports to relate. (pp. 106, 110)

Unquestionably there are sections which illustrate diversity of view and standpoint [such as futuristic resurrection sayings in John 5:28–29; cf. 6:39–40, 44, 54]... the question then arises whether, apart from divergence of conception relative to the sending of the Paraclete, the self-same author who can apparently dispense with an external Parousia has nevertheless had resort to the turns and phrases of Jewish Eschatology, or whether the sections do not rather indicate the hand of one who still clung to materialistic conceptions of Resurrection, of Judgement, of the Second Coming of the Lord. (p. 119)

Turning to the Prologue (John 1:1–18), we are confronted by a twofold question:—do we possess it in its original form—from whose pen does it come? No doubt features are presented by it which, at first sight, might dispose us to differentiate between hand and hand. They are present in John 1:6–8 and 15; where, with abrupt transition from "great abstract conceptions," we seem, if only for a moment, "to touch the solid earth," and then "are taken back to the region of abstractions which we had hardly left"; and the suggestion is not far-fetched that they are no part of the original text. It might well be pleaded that no real loss is involved by their removal; that, on the contrary, they seem but to impair the ordered sequence of majestic cadences. (p. 121)

The identity of the Evangelist is, and probably will remain, an enigma. Whether the Beloved Disciple (who is not the Apostle John) or some other person be the author, the Gospel was certainly not written by a tour de force; prolonged and careful preparation was involved; long time on the literary stocks, it was built up in collaboration with members of an inner circle. He himself never published it; when first it emerged from its depository he had, in all likelihood, already gone to his rest; and, when actually given to the world, it had, so to speak, ceased to be his Gospel to become our Fourth Gospel. Or in other words, the original treatise of the Evangelist had been somewhat freely dealt with—supplemented, interpolated, and perhaps modified—by editorial hands, yet so as to lend the semblance of compactness to the expanded work... there is no settling the question as to who precisely they were, yet it may be said of them that, for all their diversity, they belonged to the Johannine school at Ephesus. (pp. 122–123)

The Synoptic tradition was not simply explained by him, but, in and by his interpretation of it, purified and refined as he transferred the Jesus of Capernaum to Ephesus, and sought to make the Christ of his experience a reality for Hellenistic and Hellenic modes of thought... That, prior to its publication, it should be subjected to a revision which savored of conventionalism was, perhaps, natural in the circumstances; nor is there ground for wonder that, even when so worked over as to become our Fourth Gospel, it was slow—as seems to have been the case—to win its way to general acceptance... For the larger part of evidence relative to the earthly life of Jesus we must admit dependence on the Synoptics. (pp. 129–132)

Hermetic Literature and Unitarian Christology: Kegan A. Chandler (2017)

In a seventy-page conference study, "Hermes & John: The Fourth Gospel in the Early Gnostic World" (presented at the 26th Annual Theological Conference, Atlanta Bible College, Morrow, GA, April 2017), religious historian Kegan A. Chandler investigates the Fourth Gospel's direct engagement with early Greco-Egyptian Hermeticism and proto-Gnostic spirituality. Challenging the contention that Palestinian or rabbinic Judaism alone can account for every feature of Johannine discourse, Chandler argues that the Fourth Evangelist crafted a deliberate "multi-front polemic": defending Jesus' messiahship against synagogue objections on one hand, while competing with rising Hermetic-Gnostic trends in the Hellenistic world on the other.

By appropriating and reshaping terminology familiar from Hermetic religion—such as divine Logos, spiritual rebirth from above, ascent, and saving knowledge of the Father—the Evangelist sought both to persuade Greek-speaking seekers and to retain members of his own community drawn toward esoteric Hellenism. Crucially, Chandler concludes that reading John over against Hermetic cosmology undercuts later Nicene and preexistence readings of Johannine Christology:

Ultimately, a careful analysis of GJohn's deliberate contrast with early Hermetic teaching will reveal serious implications for orthodox readings of John's Christology, namely, that John's Jesus is a genuine human being who does not literally pre-exist or share a substance with God. (Kegan A. Chandler, "Hermes & John: The Fourth Gospel in the Early Gnostic World," 26th Annual Theological Conference, Atlanta Bible College, April 2017, Abstract, p. 1)